Corcoran et al v. CVS Health Corporation

Northern District of California, cand-4:2015-cv-03504

ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT'S ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL RE: SUMMARY JUDGMENT BRIEFING [*AS MODIFIED BY THE COURT *] by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers; granting 281 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. The Clerk shall permanently Lock Docket number 301-32; granting in part Motion to seal re 321 Motion to Remove Incorrectly Filed Document.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

0 1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 2 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 3 OAKLAND DIVISION 4 CHRISTOPHER CORCORAN, et al., No. 15-CV-03504-YGR 5 Plaintiffs, 6 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING v. DEFENDANT'S ADMINISTRATIVE 7 MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL RE: CVS PHARMACY, INC., SUMMARY JUDGMENT BRIEFING 8 Defendant. Dkt. Nos. 281, 321 9 *AS MODIFIED BY THE COURT* 10 11 CVS Pharmacy, Inc. ("CVS") filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal re: 12 Summary Judgment Briefing ("Motion to Seal") in the above-captioned action on June 6, 2017 13 pursuant to Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. CVS also inadvertently filed another Exhibit, DX 456 14 (Dkt. No. 301-32), in the public docket, which contained Plaintiffs' private medical information. 15 CVS has now requested the Court lock that Exhibit and re-filed it under seal. Dkt. No. 321. 16 Plaintiffs filed a declaration in support of filing their private health information under seal, but 17 otherwise took no position as to CVS's other requests. See Sweeney Decl. (filed July 12, 2017). 18 For good cause appearing, the Court GRANTS CVS's request. The Clerk shall PERMANENTLY 19 LOCK Docket Number 301-32. 20 The Court, having considered CVS's Motion to Seal, all papers and evidence submitted 21 in support, the pertinent pleadings, and the applicable law, and finding compelling reasons and 22 good cause therefore, hereby GRANTS IN PART the Motion to Seal. It is ORDERED that the 23 following materials are to be filed under seal pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5(b) and (e): 24 // 25 // 26 // 27 // 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -1- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 2 Order Document or Portion of Document Evidence Offered in 3 Sought to Be Sealed Support of Sealing 4 GRANT DX-006 (Plaintiff Carolyn Caine's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.a; 5 Amended Responses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 6 to Defendant's Interrogatories (July 7 22, 2016)) at page 3 line 20; page 7 8 line 22; and page 8 lines 12-13. 9 10 GRANT DX-028 (Plaintiff Robert Jenks' Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 11 Amended Responses and Objections 5.b; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 12 to Defendant's Interrogatories (July 13 22, 2016)) at page 3 lines 20-23; 14 page 8 lines 2-3, 16-17, 21-22, and 15 26; and page 9 lines 8-9 16 GRANT DX-083 (Plaintiff Walter Wulff's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.c; 17 Amended Responses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 18 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 19 1, 2016)) at page 3 lines 18-19; page 20 7 lines 17-18; and page 8 lines 10, 21 15, and 18-19. 22 GRANT 23 DX-092 (Plaintiff Zachary Hagert's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 24 Amended Responses and Objections 5.d; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 25 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 26 5, 2016)) at page 3 lines 20-25; page 27 8 lines 2 and l4-15. GRANT 28 DX-102 (Plaintiff Toni Odorisio's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.e; [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -2- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 Amended Reponses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 2 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 3 1, 2016)) at page 3 line 21; page 7 4 lines 17-19; page 8 lines 9, 14-15, 5 and 19-20; and page 9 lines 1-2, 6-7, 6 and 12. 7 GRANT DX-118 (Plaintiff Onnolee Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.f; 8 Samuelson's Third Amended Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 9 Responses and Objections to 10 Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 11 17, 2016)) at page 3 lines 18-19; 12 page 7 lines 20-21; page 8 lines 10, 13 14-15, 18-19, and 23; page 9 lines 1, 14 5-6, 10, 15, 20, and 25; page 10 lines 15 2-3, 7, 12, 17, 22-23; and page 11 16 lines 1-2 and 7. 17 GRANT DX-165 (Plaintiff Vincent Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 18 Gargiulo's Second Amended 5.g; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 19 Responses and Objections to 20 Defendant's Interrogatories Aug. 27, 21 2016)) at page 3 lines 20-21; and 22 page 8 lines 6-7, 21, and 25-26. 23 GRANT DX-185 (Plaintiff Carl Washington's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 24 Amended Responses and Objections 5.h; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 25 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 26 23, 2016)) at page 3 lines 18-21; 27 page 7 line 27; and page 8 lines 15, 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -3- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 20, and 24-25. 2 GRANT DX-193 (Plaintiff Amanda Gilbert's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.i; 3 Amended Responses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 4 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 5 25, 2016)) at page 3 lines 19-22; 6 page 8 at lines 10-13, 23; page 9 7 lines 4, 11-12, 17, and 21-22; and 8 page 10 lines 1-2, 5-6, and 10-11. 9 GRANT DX-201 (Plaintiff Zulema Avis's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.j; 10 Amended Responses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 11 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 12 1, 2016)) at page 3 line 18; page 7 13 lines 17-18; page 8 lines 6-7, 10-11; 14 and page 9 line 7. 15 GRANT DX-217 (Plaintiff Debbie Barrett's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 16 Second Amended Responses and 5.k;; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 17 Objections to Defendant's 18 Interrogatories (Sept. 13, 2016)) at 19 page 3 lines 18-20; page 7 lines 25- 20 26; page 8 lines 13-14, 17-18, 21-22, 21 25-26; page 9 lines 2-3, 6-7, 10-11, 22 18-19, 22-23, 26; page 10 lines 1, 4- 23 5, 8-9, 12-13, 16-17, 20-21, 24-25; 24 page 11 lines 2-3, 6-7, 10-11, 18-19, 25 22-23, 26; and page 12 lines 1, 4-5, 26 8-9. 27 GRANT DX-218 (Plaintiff Robert Garber's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.l; 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -4- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 Amended Responses and Objections Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 2 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Aug. 3 1, 2016)) at page 3 line 18; page 7 4 lines 15-18; page 8 lines 6-7, 10-11, 5 14-15, 19-20, 24-25; page 9 lines 1- 6 2, 6-7, 11, 15-16, 19-20, 24; page 10 7 lines 2-3, 8, 17, 21-22; and page 11 8 lines 1-2, 7, and 12. 9 GRANT DX-239 (Plaintiff Gilbert Brown's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 10 Amended Responses and 5.m; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 11 Objection's to Defendant's 12 Interrogatories (Oct. 5, 2016)) at 13 page 3 line 19; page 7 line 18; and 14 page 8 lines 1-2, 5-6, 10-11. 15 GRANT DX-258 (Plaintiff Tyler Clark's Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 16 Supplemental and Amended 5.n; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 17 Responses and Objections to 18 Defendant's Interrogatories (Oct. 7, 19 2016)) at page 3 line 18; page 7 line 20 24; and page 8 lines 11-12, 15-16. 21 GRANT IN PART, DX-266 (Medco Pharmacy Services Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.a except as to sections 22 Manual (2009/2010)) relating to: 1) Usual & 23 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 24 Third-Party beneficiaries 25 GRANT DX-270 (Plaintiff Christopher Moffatt Declaration 5, 5.o; 26 Corcoran's Supplemental and Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 27 Amended Responses and Objections 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -5- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 to Defendant's Interrogatories (Oct. 2 7, 2016)) at page 3 lines 18-19; page 3 7 lines 22-24; page 8 lines 14, 18-19, 4 24; page 9 lines 2-3, 8, 13, 18-19, 5 23; page 10 lines 3-4, 8, 12-13, 16- 6 17, 21; and page 11 lines 1-2, 6-7, 7 13-14, and 18. 8 GRANT IN PART, DX-300 (MedImpact Pharmacy Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4b except as to sections 9 Network Agreement (Feb. 1, 2008)) relating to: 1) Usual & 10 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 11 Third-Party beneficiaries 12 GRANT IN PART, DX-408 (Expert Report of Brett E. Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 6, 6.a except as to paragraphs 13 Barlag (Dec. 9, 2016)) at page 8 ¶ 72. 14 22; page 11 ¶ 27.c, Fig. 1, fn. 8; page 15 12 ¶ 29; page 13 ¶¶ 33-37; page 15 16 Fig. 4; page 17 Fig. 7; page 18 Fig. 17 9; page 19 ¶ 51; page 24 Fig. 12, ¶ 18 65; page 25 ¶¶ 66-68; page 26 ¶¶ 68- 19 71, Fig. 13, fn. 60; page 27 ¶ 72; 20 page 29 Fig. 16; page 38 ¶¶ 102-103; 21 page 39 ¶ 105, fns. 92-93; page 40 ¶ 22 106; page 42 ¶¶ (b), 116; page 43 ¶¶ 23 116-118, Fig. 20; page 44 Fig. 21; 24 page 47 ¶ 124, fn. 108; Appendix A; 25 Appendix D; and Appendix E 26 GRANT IN PART, DX-409 (Rebuttal Report of Brett E. Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 6, 6.b except as to paragraphs 27 Barlag (Jan. 27, 2017)) at page 3 fn. 23 and 23.b 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -6- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 3; page 11 ¶¶ 23, 23.b; page 12 ¶¶ 2 23.b, 26, fn. 28; page 13 ¶ 27; page 3 14 ¶¶ 28-29, Fig. 7; page 15 ¶¶ 29- 4 31, page 16 ¶ 32, Fig. 8; page 17 ¶¶ 5 36.a, 36.b, fn. 39; page 19 ¶ 38; and 6 Appendix B; 7 GRANT IN PART, DX-425 (Declaration of Susan Moffatt Omnibus except as to paragraph 8 Colbert (Nov. 21, 2016)) at page 1 Declaration ¶ 27(b) 13. The specific 9 Condor Codes ¶¶ 3-4; page 2 ¶¶ 7-9; page 3 ¶¶ 9- referenced therein may 10 remain sealed. 12; page 4 ¶¶13-14; page 5 ¶¶ 14-16; 11 and page 6 ¶18. 12 GRANT IN PART, DX-446 (Express Scripts Provider Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.c except as to sections 13 Manual (2014)) relating to: 1) Usual & 14 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 15 Third-Party beneficiaries 16 GRANT IN PART, DX-447 (Seventh Amendment to Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.d except as to sections 17 Express Scripts, Inc. Pharmacy relating to: 1) Usual & 18 Customary definitions Provider Agreement (Feb. 11, 2013) and provisions; and 2) 19 Third-Party beneficiaries 20 GRANT DX-459 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 21 Plaintiff Zulema Avis (Aug. 5, 5.p; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 22 2016)) at page 142 lines 7-14; and 23 page 144 lines 8-14. 24 GRANT DX-464 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 25 Plaintiff Christopher Corcoran (Nov. 5.q; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 26 2, 2016)) at page 84 lines 9-10; and 27 page 85 lines 6-8, 19-20, 23-24. 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -7- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 GRANT DX-466 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.r; 2 Plaintiff Vincent Garguilo (Aug. 27, Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 3 2016)) at page 128 lines 22-23; page 4 130 lines 17-19, 21-24; page 132 5 lines 8-11; page 174 lines 19-22; and 6 page 176 lines 15-21. 7 GRANT DX-467 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.s; 8 Plaintiff Amanda Gilbert (Sept. 7, Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 9 2016)) at page 82 lines 18-20; page 10 85 lines 18-24; page 148 lines 2-5; 11 and page 149 lines 4-7. 12 GRANT DX-469 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 5.t; 13 Plaintiff Robert Jenks (July 28, Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 14 2016)) at page 138 lines 4, 16, 21; 15 page 139 lines 2, 6, 16, 18, 19; page 16 140 lines 4, 11, 17, 26; page 207 line 17 18; page 208 lines 6, 17, 25; and 18 page 209 line 13 19 GRANT DX-472 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 20 Plaintiff Carl Washington (Aug. 30, 5.u; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 21 2016)) at page 190 lines 3-4; page 22 101 lines 8, 20; page 192 lines 5; 23 page 269 lines 3; and page 306 lines 24 2-3, 8. 25 GRANT DX-473 (Deposition Excerpts of Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 5, 26 Plaintiff Walter Wulff (Aug. 9, 5.v; Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 27 2016)) at page 72 line 21; and page 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -8- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 73 at line 25 2 GRANT IN PART, PX-532 (Express Scripts, Inc. Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.e except as to sections 3 Pharmacy Provider Agreement (Jan. relating to: 1) Usual & 4 Customary definitions 18, 2008)) and provisions; and 2) 5 Third-Party beneficiaries 6 GRANT IN PART, PX-546 (PCS Health Systems, Inc. Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.f except as to sections 7 Provider Agreement (Mar. 31, relating to: 1) Usual & 8 Customary definitions 1997)) and provisions; and 2) 9 Third-Party beneficiaries 10 GRANT IN PART, PX-551 (Medco Pharmacy Services Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.g except as to sections 11 Manual (2009)) relating to: 1) Usual & 12 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 13 Third-Party beneficiaries 14 GRANT IN PART, PX-615 (Express Scripts Network Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.h except as to sections 15 Provider Manual (2010)) relating to: 1) Usual & 16 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 17 Third-Party beneficiaries 18 GRANT IN PART, PX-674 (OptumRx, Inc. Pharmacy Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.i except as to sections 19 Network Agreement (Jan. 29, 2015)) relating to: 1) Usual & 20 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 21 Third-Party beneficiaries 22 GRANT IN PART, PX-677 (Medco Health Solutions, Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.j except as to sections 23 Inc. Retail Pharmacy Agreement relating to: 1) Usual & 24 Customary definitions (Jan. 1, 2005) and provisions; and 2) 25 Third-Party 26 beneficiaries GRANT IN PART, PX-679 (Caremark Provider Manual Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4.k except as to sections 27 (2016)) relating to: 1) Usual & 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -9- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 0 1 Customary definitions and provisions; and 2) 2 Third-Party 3 beneficiaries GRANT IN PART, PX-695 (Prescription Solutions Moffatt Declaration ¶¶ 4, 4l except as to sections 4 Prescription Drug Services relating to: 1) Usual & 5 Customary definitions Agreement (June 1, 1999)) and provisions; and 2) 6 Third-Party 7 beneficiaries GRANT IN PART, 8 PX-703 (Network Performance, Moffatt Declaration 7, 7.a except as to sections Troubleshooting Set Price Generic relating to: 1) Usual & 9 Customary definitions Programs (Oct. 1, 2008)) and provisions; and 2) 10 Third-Party 11 beneficiaries GRANT IN PART, 12 PX-785 (Aetna Health Management Moffatt Declaration 4, 4.m except as to sections National Pharmacy Services relating to: 1) Usual & 13 Customary definitions 14 Agreement (Jan. 15, 2009) and provisions; and 2) Third-Party 15 beneficiaries 16 17 Additional document to be sealed in response to CVS Motion to Remove Incorrectly Filed 18 Document (Dkt. No. 321): 19 Document or Portion of Document Evidence Offered in Support of Order 20 Sought to Be Sealed Sealing 21 DX-456 – Plaintiffs' prescription records Sweeney Decl. ¶¶ 5-6 GRANT 22 23 24 This Order terminates Docket Numbers 281 and 321. 25 IT IS SO ORDERED. 26 Dated: ______________ September 5, 2017 ______________________ 27 Hon. Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers United States District Court 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING - 10 - ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR