Corcoran et al v. CVS Health Corporation

Northern District of California, cand-4:2015-cv-03504

ORDER by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers granting in part 170 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Materials Designated as Confidential.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 2 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 3 OAKLAND DIVISION 4 CHRISTOPHER CORCORAN, et al., No. 15-CV-03504-YGR 5 Plaintiffs, 6 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING, IN v. PART, PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE 7 MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL CVS PHARMACY, INC., MATERIALS DESIGNATED AS 8 CONFIDENTIAL [DKT. NO. 170] Defendant. 9 10 11 Plaintiffs filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Materials Designated as 12 Confidential ("Motion to Seal") in the above-captioned action on October 3, 2016 pursuant to 13 Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. See Dkt. No. 170. 14 The Court, having considered Plaintiffs' Motion to Seal, all papers and evidence 15 submitted in support, the pertinent pleadings, and the applicable law, and finding compelling 16 reasons and good cause therefore, hereby GRANTS IN PART the Motion to Seal. It is 17 ORDERED that the following materials are to be filed under seal pursuant to Civil Local Rule 18 79-5(b) and (e): 19 Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification & Exhibits Thereto 20 Document or Portion of Document Evidence Offered in Support of Order 21 Sought to Be Sealed Sealing 22 Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Moffatt Omnibus Declaration (Feb. GRANT 23 Certification ("Class Cert. 15, 2017) ("Moffatt Omnibus 24 Mot.") at page 2, lines 7–9, page Declaration") ¶ 6(a) 25 5 lines 18–24, page 6 lines 14– 26 17, page 7 lines 1–2, page 10 27 lines 22–24, page 17 lines 27– 28 28, and page 21 lines 18–19; and [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -1- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 Footnote 6 (partial) 2 3 Class Cert. Mot. at page 2 lines 14– Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 6(b) GRANT 4 16, page 6 lines 11–13, page 8 lines 5 16–23, page 9 lines 3–7, page 11 6 lines 8–12, page 11 lines 27–28; and 7 Footnote 12 8 Class Cert. Mot. at page 5 lines 11– Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 6(c) GRANT 9 13, page 8 lines 6–12, page 8 lines 10 15–16, page 9 lines 8–21, page 22 11 line 28–page 23 line 2; and Footnote 12 10 (partial) 13 Class Cert. Mot. at page 6 lines 3–5; Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 6(d) GRANT 14 and Footnote 7 15 Plaintiffs' Trial Plan at page 4 line Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 7 GRANT 16 17–page 5 line 4; and Footnotes 2, 3, 17 and 6 18 Ex. 1 (Scott Tierney Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 19 (Sept. 13, 2016)) 10(a) 20 Ex. 2 (Declaration of Robert Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 21 Navarro (undated)) at Paragraphs 14(a) 22 21, 26, 34, 40, 43, 45, 47–50 and 23 Footnotes 23, 28, 31, 33, 59, 64, 67, 24 and 78 25 Ex. 3 (Hilary Dudley Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 26 (Sept. 20, 2016)) 10(b) 27 Ex. 4 (Health Savings Pass Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(a) GRANT 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -2- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 Reconciliation Process—Policy) 2 Ex. 6 (Robert Greenwood Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 3 (Sept. 28, 2016)) 10(c) 4 Ex. 7 (Thomas Gibbons Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 5 (Sep. 30, 2014)) 11(a) 6 Ex. 8 (Susan Colbert Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 7 (Oct. 1, 2014)) 11(b) 8 Ex. 9 (Paul Ferschke Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 9 (Dec. 19, 2014)) 11(c) 10 Ex. 11 (Sevak Melkonian Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 11 (July 21, 2016)) 10(d) 12 Ex. 12 ("CVS Contracts Included in Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 13 the Class") 13(a) 14 Ex. 13 (Pharmacy Provider Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 15 Agreement – Amendment No. 2 12(a) 16 between Humana Health Plan, Inc., 17 Humana Insurance Company, and 18 CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (Jan. 1, 2005)) 19 Ex. 14 (MedCare Pharmacy Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 20 Network Agreement between 12(b) 21 MedImpact Healthcare System, Inc. 22 and CVS Pharmacy, Inc. (Feb. 1, 23 2008)) 24 GRANTS with Ex. 15 (Declaration of Joel Hay Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ regard to ¶¶ 31– 25 (Oct. 3, 2016)) at Paragraphs 2, 9– 14(b) 34, 38, 40–43; 26 52–55; 10, 12–13, 27–28, 31–34, 38, 40–43, footnotes 10 27 and 14; Tables 50, 52–55; Footnotes 10 and 14; 1–17; DENIES 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -3- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 as to all others Subheadings IV.A.i.–iii and IV.D.– 2 E.; and Tables 1–17 3 Ex. 17 (Email from P. Ferschke to T. Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(b) GRANT 4 Morrison (Apr. 9, 2008)) 5 Ex. 18 (Email from Bari Harlam to Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(c) GRANT 6 Tom Morrison (May 14, 2008)) 7 Ex. 19 (Email from Sue Colbert to Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(d) GRANT 8 Tom Morrison (Aug. 4, 2008)) 9 Ex. 21 (list of CVS "Agency ID" Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(e) GRANT 10 codes) 11 Ex. 22 (CVS/Pharmacy Health Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(f) GRANT 12 Savings Pass—Policy & Procedure 13 No. 58) 14 Ex. 24 (Email and attached slide Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(g) GRANT 15 deck titled "CVS/pharmacy: Cash 16 card program offering 17 recommendations (May 9, 2008)") 18 Ex. 25 (Email from S. Gruttadauria Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(h) GRANT 19 to S. Tierney & B. Wingate (July 20 9, 2010)) 21 Ex. 26 ((Email and slide deck titled Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 9(i) GRANT 22 "CVS Pharmacy: Landscape 23 Strategy Document (June 25, 24 2010)") 25 Ex. 27 ("Chart of Plaintiff Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 26 Contracts") 13(b) 27 Ex. 40 (Brian Hughes Transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -4- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 (July 27, 2016)) at page 8 lines 18– 10(e) 2 21 3 4 It is further ORDERED that the following materials are to be filed on the public docket without 5 redaction within five business days. For these materials, the Designating Party of the allegedly 6 confidential information therein has stated that the materials need not be redacted or filed under 7 seal. 8 9 Document or Portion of Document Order 10 Class Cert. Mot. at page 5 line 13 GRANT 11 (partial), page 7 lines 8–11, 12 page 7 lines 22–24, page 21 lines 13 10–12; and Footnotes 6 (partial) 14 and 10 (partial) 15 Plaintiffs' Trial Plan at page 5 lines GRANT 16 16–20 17 Ex. 5 (Email from Kevin Foster GRANT 18 attaching slide deck titled 19 "THIRD PARTY FINANCE 20 GLOSSARY OF TERMS") 21 Ex. 10 (Thomas Morrison Transcript GRANT 22 (July 20, 2016)) 23 Ex. 16 (CVS Health Savings Pass GRANT 24 website (Nov. 1, 2008–May 25 2015)) 26 Ex. 20 (Email from Elizabeth GRANT 27 Wingate to Mark Dowling (Sept. 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -5- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 12, 2008)) 2 Ex. 40 (Brian Hughes Transcript GRANT 3 (July 27, 2016)) except for page 4 8 lines 18–21 5 6 7 Dated: March 21, 2017_____ ______________________ 8 Hon. Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers United States District Court 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -6- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 170, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR