Corcoran et al v. CVS Health Corporation

Northern District of California, cand-4:2015-cv-03504

ORDER by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers granting in part 205 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Materials Designated as Confidential.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 2 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 3 OAKLAND DIVISION 4 CHRISTOPHER CORCORAN, et al., No. 15-CV-03504-YGR 5 Plaintiffs, 6 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING, IN v. PART, PLAINTIFFS' ADMINISTRATIVE 7 MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL CVS PHARMACY, INC., MATERIALS DESIGNATED AS 8 CONFIDENTIAL [DKT. NO. 205] Defendant. 9 10 11 Plaintiffs filed an Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Materials Designated as 12 Confidential ("Motion to Seal") in the above-captioned action on December 19, 2016 pursuant to 13 Local Rules 7-11 and 79-5. See Dkt. No. 205. 14 The Court, having considered Plaintiffs' Motion to Seal, all papers and evidence 15 submitted in support, the pertinent pleadings, and the applicable law, and finding compelling 16 reasons and good cause therefore, hereby GRANTS IN PART the Motion to Seal. It is 17 ORDERED that the following materials are to be filed under seal pursuant to Civil Local Rule 18 79-5(b) and (e): 19 Plaintiffs' Navarro Opposition & Exhibits Thereto 20 Document or Portion of Document Evidence Offered in Support of Order 21 Sought to Be Sealed Sealing 22 Plaintiffs' Opposition to CVS Pharmacy, Moffatt Omnibus Declaration GRANT 23 Inc.'s Motion to Exclude Certain (Feb. 15, 2017) ("Moffatt 24 Opinion Testimony of Dr. Robert Omnibus Declaration") ¶ 19(a) 25 Navarro ("Opp.") at page 13 line 11– 26 page 14 line 13, and page 14 lines 17– 27 19 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING -1- ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. NO. 205, NO. 15-CV-03504-YGR 1 Opp. at page 15 line 25–page 16 line 3 Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 2 19(b) 3 Opp. at page 18 lines 12–20 Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 4 19(c) 5 GRANTS Ex. 1 (Declaration of Robert Navarro (Oct. Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 21 with regard 6 3, 2016)) at paragraphs 7–8, 10, 12–14, 20, to ¶¶ 26, 7 34, 42–50, 21 (partial), 25, 26 (partial), 28, 34, 36, 40 Footnotes 8 23, 31, 59; (partial), 41–44, 45 (partial), 46, 47 DENIES as 9 to all (partial), 48–50, 52; and Footnotes 23, 28 others 10 (partial), 31 (partial), 33, 59, 64 (partial), 11 67, 78 12 Ex. 2 (Thomas Gibbons Transcript (Sep. Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 22 GRANT 13 30, 2014)) 14 Ex. 3 (Dr. Robert Navarro Transcript (Nov. Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 15 7, 2016)) (partial) at page 126 lines 1–20 10(b) 16 Ex. 9 (a November 2, 2006 email regarding Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 17 "Usual and Customary (U&C) pricing 24(a) 18 provision reminder") 19 Ex. 10 ("October Pharmacy Supervisor Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 20 Conference Call Recap") 24(b) 21 Ex. 11 (a January 19, 2009 email regarding Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 22 "Medco Provider Manual") 24(c) 23 Ex. 12 (a May 8, 2008 email transmitting a Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 24 presentation titled "Cash Card Offering May 24(d) 25 9 2008 v2") 26 Ex. 13 (Scott Tierney deposition transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 27 excerpts (Sept. 13, 2016)) 25(a) 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING ADMIN. -2- MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. 205 1 Ex. 14 (Sevak Melkonian deposition Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 2 transcript excerpts (July 21, 2016)) 25(b) 3 Ex. 15 (Hilary Dudley deposition transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 4 excerpts (Sept. 20, 2016)) 25(c) 5 Ex. 16 (an April 9, 2008 email thread Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 6 regarding "Cash card discussion with Larry") 24(e) 7 Ex. 17 (an August 3-4, 2008 email thread Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 8 regarding "CVS Caremark Cash Offering") 24(f) 9 Ex. 18 (a May 14, 2008 email regarding Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 10 "Cash Card") 24(g) 11 Ex. 20 (a May 8, 2014 document titled Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 26 GRANT 12 "Responses of CVS Pharmacy, Inc. to 13 Demand for Written Statement Under 14 Oath.") 15 Ex. 21 (a June 5, 2012 email and Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 16 attachments regarding "Payer Relations 24(h) 17 Policy and Procedures") 18 Ex. 22 (William Strein deposition Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 19 transcript excerpts (December 12, 2016)) 27(a) 20 Ex. 23 (Franceen Spadaccino deposition Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 21 transcript excerpts (December 13, 2016)) 27(b) 22 Ex. 24 (Amber Compton deposition Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 23 transcript excerpts (December 16, 2016)) 27(c) 24 Ex. 25 (William Barre deposition transcript Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 25 excerpts (Nov. 17, 2016)) 27(d) 26 Ex. 19 (Email from Sue Colbert to Tom Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ DENIED1 27 28 1 It appears that this exhibit and the four exhibits following through Exhibit 25 (July 9, [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING ADMIN. -3- MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. 205 1 Morrison (Aug. 4, 2008)) 9(d) 2 Ex. 21 (list of CVS "Agency ID" codes) Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ DENIED 3 9(e) 4 Ex. 22 (CVS/Pharmacy Health Savings Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ DENIED 5 Pass—Policy & Procedure No. 58) 9(f) 6 Ex. 24 (Email and attached slide deck titled Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ DENIED 7 "CVS/pharmacy: Cash card program 9(g) 8 offering recommendations (May 9, 2008)") 9 Ex. 25 (Email from S. Gruttadauria to S. Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ DENIED 10 Tierney & B. Wingate (July 9, 2010)) 9(h) 11 Ex. 26 (a June 19, 2012 letter from the Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ 28 GRANT 12 United States Department of Justice) 13 Ex. 27 (Sharon Edmunds deposition Moffatt Omnibus Declaration ¶ GRANT 14 transcript excerpts (August 16, 2016)) 25(d) 15 16 It is further ORDERED that the following materials are to be filed on the public docket without 17 redaction within five business days. For these materials, the Designating Party of the allegedly 18 confidential information therein has stated that the materials need not be redacted or filed under 19 seal. 20 21 Document or Portion of Document Order 22 Opp. at page 14 lines 14–16 and GRANT 23 page 18 lines 20–24 (partial) 24 25 26 27 2010 Email) refer to documents subject to the administrative sealing motion at Docket Number 170. Such have been addressed by a separate sealing order, and the Court thus denies the 28 requests in this order as moot. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING ADMIN. -4- MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. 205 1 Ex. 3 (Dr. Robert Navarro GRANT 2 Transcript (Nov. 7, 2016)) 3 except for page 126 lines 1–20 4 Ex. 19 (Email from Elizabeth GRANT 5 Wingate to Mark Dowling (Sept. 6 12, 2008)) 7 8 9 Dated: March ______________ 21, 2017 ______________________ Hon. Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers 10 United States District Court 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING ADMIN. -5- MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL DKT. 205