Data Scape Limited v. Dropbox, Inc.

Western District of Texas, txwd-6:2019-cv-00023

Affidavit

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

2 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS WACO DIVISION DATA SCAPE LTD., Civil Action No. 6:19-cy-00023 Plaintiff, DROPBOX, INC., Defendant. DECLARATION OF GREGORY H. LANTIER IN SUPPORT OF DROPBOX'S MOTION TO TRANSFER VENUE TO THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA I, Gregory H. Lantier, hereby declare: 1. I am an attorney admitted to practice in the District of Columbia, the State of New York, and the State of Virginia, and have been admitted pro hac vice in this action. I am a partner at the law firm of Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP ("WilmerHale"), counsel for Defendant Dropbox Inc. ("Dropbox") in the above-captioned action. I provide this declaration in support of Dropbox's Motion to Transfer Venue. 2. Unless otherwise indicated below, the statements in this declaration are based on my personal knowledge and my review of the documents cited herein. If called to testify as a witness, I could and would competently do so under oath. 3. Attached as Exhibit 1 is a true and correct of a printout from the Vision-net profile of Data Scape, available at https://www.vision-net.ie/Company-Info/Data-Scape-Limited- 595810 (last visited April 23, 2019). 2 4. Attached as Exhibit 2 is a true and correct copy of printouts from the Docket Navigator profile of Data Scape, located at https://compass.docketnavigator.com/patent/party/486769/0 (last visited April 23, 2019). 5. Attached as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of a printout from the LinkedIn profile of Ben Newhouse, located at https://www.linkedin.com/in/ben-newhouse-3102253/ (last visited April 23, 2019). 6. Attached as Exhibit 4 is a true and correct copy of a printout from the LinkedIn profile of Kelly Marren, located at https://www.linkedin.com/in/kellymarren/ (last visited April 23, 2019). 7. Attached hereto as Exhibit 5 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between the Court for the Waco Division of the Western District of Texas and Dropbox's San Francisco headquarters, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Headquarters,+Brannan+Street,+San+Francisco,+C C/US+District+Court,+800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701/@34.3272587,- 118.7674731,5z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m 14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x808f7fd73b009b2b:Oxb750867660 0711a5!2m2!1d- 122.3926982!2d37.7810569!1m5!1m1!1s0x864f824d09353335:0xb32613db496ef993!2m2!1d- 97.1332879!2d31.552983!3e0 (last visited April 23, 2019). 8. Attached hereto as Exhibit 6 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between the Court for the San Francisco Division of the Northern District of California and Dropbox's San Francisco headquarters, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Headquarters,+Brannan+Street,+San+Francisco,+C C/US+District+Court+Clerk,+Golden+Gate+Avenue,+San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7796652,- 2 Exhibit 3 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA DocurtierreBlephouselelehk@!/24/19 Page 12 of 42 O O À O © o * Q Search Try Premium Free Try Premium Free for 1 Month Attorney Needed ASAP - Crucial need for local attorney in your area. View new cases today. Ad .. Promoted Online MA in Psychology Apply now for Pepperdine's online! in Psychology program. No GRE req Attorney Needed ASAP Crucial need for local attorney in yo area. View new cases today. Berkeley Haas The Berkeley MBA Same degree, different schedules, Evening. Weekend. Executive. Full- time. Stanford University People Also Viewed Ben Newhouse · 3rd Taking 2018 off San Francisco, California O See contact info 88 131 connections M Todd Farrell - 3rd in Data Scientist at Second Measun Message Nahi Ojeil. 3rd Senior Director of Engineering at Dropbox I'm likely jumping back into the entrepreneurial waters after a long stint at Dropbox, but not before spending the rest of 2018 learning, travelling and spending extensive time with the folks I love. Philip LaPier. 3rd Product Designer at Pilot.com (V hiring!) Experience Jessica McKellar. 3rd in Founder and CTO at Pilot Ashley Yuki. 3rd Product Manager at Instagram Head of Sync Dropbox Apr 2014 - Apr 2018 • 4 yrs 1 mo Came via acquisition, created Project Infinite (now Smart Sync) during hack week, spun up an entire team around it that I managed through initial launch. Went on to lead all of the sync teams spanning the entire stack through IPO. lolanthe Stronger. 3rd in Merchant Core Experience @ Str I had a lot of fun, but I got what I wanted from the experience (leading larger teams) and was ready to move on Michael Wolf. 3rd Senior Staff Software Engineer at Google Co-Founder Aria Glassworks / Bubbli (Acquired by Dropbox) May 2010 - Apr 2014. 4 yrs We make the bubbli app for iOS and Android, that we never publicly released). Bubbli lets you capture spherical photos called bubbles - which are the best medium yet invented to capture what it's like to be in a moment. ... See more Tina Schuchman - 3rd Product & Engineering Leader at Dropbox Timothy Alexander PMM (Product Material Mgr) at Systems Hongyi Hu. 3rd in Security Engineering Developer Yelp.com Jun 2009 - May 2010: 1 yr Originally started on search and datamining, ended up creating the Yelp Monocle for iPhone and Android. Popular courses on LinkedIn Learning Strategic Thinking Viewers: 359,879 Innovation Engineering Group Intern Microsoft Jun 2008 - Oct 2009 - 1 yr 5 mos Why Mentoring Matte Viewers: 22,250 The Hirinn Blind Spot Lead Frontend Developer SwayLaw LLC © Messaging https://www.linkedin.com/in/ben-newhouse-3102253/ 1/2 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documerrel Dephouse belohk@d!/24/19 Page 13 of 42 O O À 0 0 o * Try Premium Free Q Search Try Premium Free for 1 Month Education Stanford University BS, Electrical Engineering © Messaging https://www.linkedin.com/in/ben-newhouse-3102253/ 2/2 2 Exhibit 4 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documéfike 2 agarrefiletkeg4/24/19 Page 15 of 42 O O À O © o * Q Search Try Premium Free Try Premium Free for 1 Month Attorney Needed ASAP - Crucial need for local attorney in your area. View new cases today. Ad .. Promoted Convenient carpools with co-workers and neighbors. Online MA in Attorney Nee Psychology ASAP Apply now for Crucial need for Pepperdine's online MA in attorney in your are Psychology program. No new cases todi GRE req'd. Learn more Learn more Scoop Technologies, Inc. People Also Viewed Kelly Marren • 3rd Product @ Scoop, Previously Dropbox San Francisco, California Stanford University Arum Kang - 3rd in Co-Founder/CEO 0 See contact info 88 500+ connections Message Gina Lau. 3rd (she/her) Director, People Ops at - We're Hiring! Experience Jonathan Sadow. 3rd in Co-Founder at Scoop (We're hiri sales, eng, marketing and more! Senior Product Manager Scoop Technologies, Inc. Jul 2018 - Present - 10 mos San Francisco Bay Area Working to bring managed carpool programs to enterprises. Jolie Kemp. 3rd Product Analytics Lead at Dropb Daniel Shapero. 3rd in VP of Global Solutions (Head of at LinkedIn Dropbox 4 yrs Kathryn Rucker. 3rd Entrepreneur and Sales Consulta Product Manager Jan 2017 - Jul 2018. 1 yr 7 mos San Francisco Bay Area Dropbox Business and Enterprise PM. Commercialized Smart Sync for all business teams • Dropbox "Hackweek" Winner (5 Winners amongst 334 projects) Veronica Wang. 3rd in Head of Growth Product @ Brex Scott Hulbert. 3rd CTO @ Scoop Bringing Dropbox Smart Sync to all... Mindy Zhang - 3rd Product @ Dropbox Enterprise Solutions Architect Aug 2015 - Jul 2017 - 2 yrs Sree Vidya Sastry. 3rd Software Engineer at Scoop • Facilitated powerful Dropbox Enterprise deployments for Dropbox's most strategic accounts. • Spoke to CIOs and at conferences about managing cloud security Show 1 more role Analyst SRECTrade Jun 2013 - Sep 2013. 4 mos San Francisco Bay Area. Modeled solar generation data to establish current market conditions and project future market supply of Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECs). Olympic Hopeful Halfpipe Snowboarder © Messaging https://www.linkedin.com/in/kellymarren/ 1/3 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documehikel2_Ngarretileck94/24/19 Page 16 of 42 O O À 0 0 o * Try Premium Free Q Search Try Premium Free for 1 Month Noteworthy Results: Olympic Hopeful 2010, 2014 Winter '13 12th Place World Snowboarding Championships Quebec, Canada... See more Research Assistant Carnegie Institution's Department of Global Ecology Sep 2012 - Jan 2013 - 5 mos Stanford, CA Examined the climate impacts of drought on forested ecosystems. Tasks included grinding and processing pine and aspen trees from the Rocky Mountains and performing total non-structural carbohydrate extraction. Acknowledged in the Plant Physiology Vol 159, 2012 in the published scientific paper. Education Stanford University Bachelor of Science (BS), Science, Technology and Society, Energy Engineering Concentration Activities and Societies: TA at Hasso Plattner Institute of Design at Stanford General Assembly Product Managment Experience in: wireframing, competitive analysis, customer-centric design, feature prioritization, agile development, and more. Volunteer Experience Science in Service Mentor Stanford Haas Center Apr 2010 - Present. 9 yrs 1 mo Education Delivered weekly science and engineering lessons to underprivileged youth, augmenting their classroom science education with hands-on experiments. Motivated mentees to purse science with intellectual curiosity and confidence. National Student Athlete Advisory Board Member Positive Coaching Alliance Apr 2008 - Jun 2010 • 2 yrs 3 mos Children Advised Positive Coaching Alliance's adult board members. Pinpointed the difficulties facing high school student-athletes then helped develop Positive Coaching Alliance's curriculum on Triple- Impact Competitors. Traveled to conferences and fundraising events to speak on behalf of the organization. Maintains a consulting relationship with the organization. © Messaging https://www.linkedin.com/in/kellymarren/ 2/3 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documlehlikel2 Marrefleckg4/24/19 Page 17 of 42 O O À 0 0 o * Try Premium Free Q Search Try Premium Free for 1 Month © Messaging https://www.linkedin.com/in/kellymarren/ 3/3 2 Exhibit 5 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-cv-00023-AD AropDo Leagoeanters Do_05 Districtor 04/250pgle Mapage 19 of 42 Google Maps Dropbox Headquarters to US District Court Drive 1,757 miles, 27 h ONTARIO TOWA Chicago NORTH WASHINGTON DAKOTA MINNESOTA Ottawa Montreal SOUTH MAIN WISCONSIN OREGON DAKOTA MICHIGAN Torontov IDAHO WYOMINO NEW YORK NA NEBRASKA CTRI ILLINOIS PENN NEVADA United States INDIANA Philadelphia UTAH COLORADO KANSAS WEST MISSOURI V ODropbox Headquarters IRGINIA KENTUCKY VIRGINIA CALCORNIA Las Vegas 27h 1.794 miles NORTH TENNESSEE CAROLINA ARIZONA MISSISSIPPI SOUTH CAROLINA 27h "OUS District Court GEORGIA 1.757 miles MDN Los Angeles San Diego North Pacific Ocean LOUISIANA Houston FLORIDA Gofof California Gulf of Mexico Mexico Honolu HAWAII HO Mexico City Dominican Republic Guatemall Canbbean Sea Nicaragua Google Caracas Costa Rica Panama Venezuel Map data ©2019 Google, INEGI 500 mic 27 h via l-40 E Fastest route, the usual traffic 1,757 miles This route has HOV only roads at certain times and days. A Your destination is in a different time zone. A via l-40 E and US-287 S 27 h 1.794 miles via 1-10 E 28 h 1,796 miles https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Headquarters, +Brannan+Street,+San+Francisco,+CC/US+District+Court,+800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+... 1/1 2 Exhibit 6 4/23/2019 Case 6:19Dcqpbo00-AQIYADA Bravoaienfae Franciscilea 104922491ig Copbgesk2$oogle\'paps Google Maps Drive 2.0 miles, 13 min Dropbox Headquarters, Brannan Street, San Francisco, CC to US District Court Clerk HUSSTAN HILL UUSTUNNEL ESIDIO OF FRANCISCO Presidio Officers Club COW HOLLOW Gough Frans EMBARCADERO San Francisco - Oakland Bay Bridge Chinatown San Francisco Fore BND Lyon Street Steps Ferry Building Marketplace Rincon Park $2 House of Prime Rib FINANCIAL DISTRICT Grace Cathedral Beach California Alta Plaza Park Lafayette Park Julius Kahn Playground PRESIDIO HEIGHTS Presidio A Union Square POLK GULCH 101 ETHE EAST CUT Camino Dent California Pine 1 ush RINCON HILL San Francisco Museum of Modern Art Geary E STREET California LAUREL HEIGHTS The Fillmore Children's Creativity Museum JORDAN PARK Target Brenda's French Soul Food US District Court Clerk The Warfield RICHMOND DISTRICT INNER RICHMOND 13 min 2.0 miles Oracle Park University of San Francisco Turk Blvd San Francisco City Hall Park Presidio Blvd Balboa S Painted Ladies 25th Ave HAYES VALLEY Fell St Fun Conservatory of Flowers PANHANDUSE Oak St LOWER HAIGHT 12 min 22 miles 13 min 20 miles Golden Gate Park CROSSOV California Academy of Sciences San Francisco Botanical Garden koret Playground Buena Vista Park California Pacific Medical Center Davies Campus 14th St Folsom Fredericks UCSF Medical Center at Mission Bay 16th Lincoln Way DE 19th Ave Irving Si University of California San Francisco 1100 INNER SUNSET ASHBURY Misión San -HEIGHTS Francisco de Asis The Castro Theatre Tortine Bakery THE CASTRO Dolores Para DOLORES 9 El Techo Seward HEIGHTS Mini Dark POTRERO HILL MI Sutro Open Space Reserve MISSION DISTRICT DOGPATCH 16th Avenue Tiled Steps | Zuckerberg San CENTRAL Map data ©2019 Google 2000 ft via Brannan St and 7th St Best route, despite the usual traffic 13 min 2.0 miles A via Harrison St Heavy traffic, as usual 13 min 2.0 miles 12 min via 9th St Heavy traffic, as usual 2.2 miles https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Headquarters,+Brannan+Street,+San+Francisco,+CC/US+District+Court+Clerk,+Golden+Gate+Avenue,+... treet,+San+Francisco,+CC/US+District+Court+Clerk,+Golden+Gate+Aver 1/1 2 Exhibit 7 4/24/2019 Case 6:19-CV-000 DepPD Seattpotumaeyat Seatle, Welpen bidraugaug - Googlgeva3 of 42 Dropbox Seattle, 5th Avenue, Seattle, WA to US Laps Dropbo Google Maps District Court Drive 2,101 miles, 33 h Saskatoon Calgary ONTARIO Winnipeg Vancouver Victoria Dropbox Seattle WASHINGTON NORTH DAKOTA MONTANA MINNESOTA Portland Minneapolis WISCONSIN SOUTH DAKOTA OREGON Toront MICHIGAN IDAHO WYOMINE Detroit Chicago NEBRASKA INDIANA OHIO NEVADA United States Kansas City Indianapolis Sacramento San Francisco R 33 h 2.101 miles MISSOURI FIRGINIA CALIFORNIA Las Vegas KENTUCKY Nastyville TENNESSEE о с Charlotte Los Angeles ARIZONA W MEXICO Atlanta SOUT CAROLI San Diego Phoenix Dallas MISSISSIPPI LABAMA GEORGIA El Paso TUCSON TEXAS OUS District Court BAJA CALIFORNIA Austin Houston Jacksonville SONORA LOUISIANA New Orleans HUA San Antonio G COAHUILA Orlando ототра FLORIDA ot Calfom NUEVO LEON Miar Google BAJA CALIFORNIA SUR SINALOA DURANGO Monterrey Gulf of Marien Mexico TAMAULIPAS Havana SAN LUIS Map data ©2019 Google, INEGI 200 mil via 1-84 E 33 h Fastest route now due to traffic 2,101 miles conditions A Your destination is in a different time zone. https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Seattle, +5th+Avenue,+Seattle, +WA/US+District+Court,+800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701/... 1/1 2 Exhibit 8 4/24/2019 Case 6:19-CV-OOOPBOAD, Drotvarne Beagle-VYA CHE di C14Y24/1Gerkpappelen of 42 Goog Maps Drop Dropbox Seattle, 5th Avenue, Seattle, WA to US District Court Clerk Drive 890 miles, 15 h 39 min Vancouver LAGXFEET Kootenai National Forest Victoria Okanogen Wenatchee National Forest Flathead National Forest LATHEAD BESERVATION Dropbox Seattle Great Fale WASHINGTON pil.com Olympia Misode Yakima MONTANA Helers YAKAMA INDIAN HESERVATION Nez Perce Clearwater National Forests Doreman Portland Payette National Forest Beaverhead-Deerlodge National Forest Balm Salmon- Challis National Forest Yellowstone National Park Bend Raise Idaho Falls Acheon Namoa IDAHO 13 h 47 min B05 miles Pocatello WYOMIN A 13 h 27 min R07 mil Twin File Ogden Salt Lake City Roding 15 h 39 min 890 miles Sandy AND OURAY VATION Provo NEVADA Reno UTAH Sacramento Humboldt-Tolyabe National Forest US District Court Clerk Palo Alto San Jose St. George Fresno CALIFORNIA Death Valley National Park Las Vegas Google NAVAD NATION Bakersfield Map data ©2019 Google, INEGI 100 mil via 1-5 S Fastest route, the usual traffic 13 h 27 min 807 miles A via US-97 S and 1-5 S 13 h 47 min 805 miles A via CA-139 S and 1-5 S A This route has tolls. 15 h 39 min 890 miles https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Seattle, +5th+Avenue, +Seattle, +WA/US+District+Court+Clerk,+450+Golden+Gate+Ave,+San+Francisco,+... w.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Seattle+ +WAJUS+District+Court+Clerk +450+Golden+Gate+Ave,+ 1/1 2 Exhibit 9 2 timeanddate.com Distance from Tokyo to San Francisco Distance is 8289 kilometers or 5151 miles or 4476 nautical miles The distance is the theoretical air distance (great circle distance). Flying between the two locations' airports can be a different distance, depending on airport location and actual route chosen. Map - Shortest path between Tokyo and San Francisco Location for Tokyo O Location for San Francisco The map is using a projection that makes land and oceans much wider near the south and north poles. The heading/course/bearing during a flight varies in most cases. Map based on image from NASA. Heading from Tokyo Latitude: 35° 41' North Longitude: Initial heading: Final heading: 139° 42' East 54.4° Northeast 123.3° East-southeast See other cities near Tokyo Calculate distance from Tokyo to another location Heading from San Francisco Latitude: Longitude: 37° 47' 122° 25' North West 2 Exhibit 10 2 timeanddate.com Distance from Tokyo to Waco Distance is 10496 kilometers or 6522 miles or 5668 nautical miles The distance is the theoretical air distance (great circle distance). Flying between the two locations' airports can be a different distance, depending on airport location and actual route chosen. Map - Shortest path between Tokyo and Waco Location for Tokyo O Location for Waco The map is using a projection that makes land and oceans much wider near the south and north poles. The heading/course/bearing during a flight varies in most cases. Map based on image from NASA. Heading from Tokyo Latitude: 35° 41' North Longitude: Initial heading: Final heading: 139° 42' East 45.7°Northeast 137.0° Southeast See other cities near Tokyo Calculate distance from Tokyo to another location Heading from Waco Latitude: 31° 33' North Longitude: 97°09' West 2 Exhibit 11 2 122.4145188,15z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x808f7fd73b009b2b:Oxb750867b6 6d711a5!2m2!1d- 122.3926982!2d37.7810569!1m5!1m1!1s0x8085809alb71c355:0xfb7672863e286a17!2m2!1d- 122.4181757!2d37.7819798!3e0 (last visited April 23, 2019). Attached as Exhibit 7 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between Dropbox's office in Seattle, Washington and the Court for the Waco Division of the Western District of Texas, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Seattle,+5th+Avenue,+Seattle,+WA/US+District+C Cour,+800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701/@39.2021462,- 118.7163462,5z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x54906ab0b04927f3:0x928e686e4b 524cfc!2m2!1d- 122.3306717!2d47.6045515!1m5!1m1!1s0x864f824d09353335:0xb32613db496ef993!2m2!1d- 97.1332879!2d31.552983!3e0 (last visited April 24, 2019). 10. Attached as Exhibit 8 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between Dropbox's office in Seattle, Washington and the Court for the San Francisco Division of the Northern District of California and Dropbox's San Francisco headquarters, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dropbox+Seattle,+5th+Avenue,+Seattle,+WA/US+District+C Cour+Clerk, +450+Golden+Gate+Ave,+San+Francisco,+CA+94102/@42.601039,- 126.4567417,6z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x54906ab0b04927f3:0x928e686e4b 524cfc!2m2!1d- 122.3306717!2d47.6045515!1m5!1m1!1s0x8085809a1b71c355:0xfb7672863e286a17!2m2!1d- 122.4181757!2d37.7819798!3e0 (last visited April 24, 2019). 2 11. Attached as Exhibit 9 is a true and correct copy of a printout from timeanddate.com showing the distance between Tokyo and San Francisco, available at https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/distanceresult.html?pl=248&p2=224 (last visited April 23, 2019). 12. Attached as Exhibit 10 is a true and correct copy of a printout from timeanddate.com showing the distance between Tokyo and Waco, available at https://www.timeanddate.com/worldclock/distanceresult.html?pl=248&p2=905 (last visited April 23, 2019). 13. Attached as Exhibit 11 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between the Court for the Waco Division of the Western District of Texas and the airport in Dallas, Texas, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/DFW+Airport,+Grapevine,+TX/US+District+Court,+800+Fra Frank+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701/@32.2178008,- 97.6324619,9z/data=!4m 15!4m14!1m5!1m1!1s0x864c2a66094076dd:0x2f80ce4db91b9cda!2m 2!1d- 97.0424508!2d32.8982972!1m5!1m1!1s0x864f824d09353335:0xb32613db496ef993!2m2!1d- 97.1332879!2d31.552983!3e0!5i2 (last visited April 23, 2019). 14. Attached as Exhibit 12 is a true and correct copy of a printout from Google Maps showing the distance between the Court for the San Francisco Division of the Northern District of California and the airport in San Francisco, California, available at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/San+Francisco+International+Airport+(SFO),+San+Francisco,+CA/US+District+Court+Clerk,+450+Golden+Gate+Ave,+San+Francisco,+CA+94102/@37.69 6942,- 4/23/2019 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADFXV Airport Graperirte 32-10 U$PietriftO-44246p9gle pange 31 of 42 Google Maps DFW Airport, Grapevine, TX to US District Court Drive 107 miles, 1 h 48 min woodson South Bend Eliasville Elasville Springtown Royse City Graford Goraford Grapevine DFW Airport 0 Garland Quinlan - Lueders Mineral Wells Irving Dallas Breckenridge Breckenridge lege Millsap Weatherford Arlington Terrell Albany 1 h 49 min 114 miles Wills Point La Casa La Caso Santo DeSoto 175 Kaufman Kaufman Canton Strawn Gordon 50 Thurber Burleson 1 h 48 min 107 miles Ranger Granbury Kemp Clyde Baird Eastlan Waxahachie Putnam Putnam Bluff Dale Cleburne Gun Ennis Belle Plain Barrel City 1 h 47 min 116 miles Rice Stephenville Glen Rose Gorman Athens Vol Cross Plains Rising Star De Leon Dublin Dublin Walnut Springs Kopper ID callscorner @ Corsicana ldsboro Kopper Hillsboro Novice Hico tradell Whitney a Cayugo Meridian Comanche Carlton Abbott Dawson Hubbard Coleman Gustine 36 Lake Brownwood West Tennessee 19 Colony Pales Cranfills Gap Clifton Valera Energy Santa Anna Wortham 71 Bangs Brownwood Fairfield Hamilton Zephyr Valley Mills Joneso Google Teague 281 Mead Lanely Oakwood Gouldbusk Mulin Brookesmith 77 US District Court Woodway 0 1 Groesbeck Whon Frant Purmela Map data ©2019 Google 10 mil via 1-35E S and 1-35 S Fastest route now due to traffic conditions 1 h 47 min 116 miles A via I-35W S and I-35 S 1 h 49 min 114 miles A via TX-360 S, 1-35W S and I-35 S A This route has tolls. 1 h 48 min 107 miles https://www.google.com/maps/dir/DFW+Airport,+Grapevine,+TX/US+District+Court,+800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701/@32.2178008,-... www.google.com/maps/dir/DFW+Airport, +Grapevine,+TX/US+District+Court, +800+Franklin+Ave+%23+304,+Waco,+TX+76701@32.2178008... 12 1/2 2 Exhibit 12 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-000830 AB)Ascq recla'tiqeahliBQ10 UF FlietdCO2/24/4r9- Gpag Maps of 42 Google Maps ans San Francisco International Airport to US District Drive 13.9 miles, 23 min voogle maps Court Clerk Alany O Lafayette VERS BELVEDERE TIBURON Orinda Berkeley Muir Beach Golden Gate Sausalito National Recreation Area Emeryville Moraga Piedmont Canyon D 0 Oakland Gulf of the Fatalones NORTH BEACH NANG ISTIC OUS District Court Clerk Alameda QUETE 8 Anthony Chabot Regional Par Bay Farm Island San Leandro Farallon Islands 27 min 18.4 miles A 23 min 13.9 miles Colma Brisbane 100 South San Francisco Castro San Lorenzo za - Нау Russell City 980 13) San Brno San Francisco International Airport Pacifica Milibre Linda Mar Eden Landir Ecological Reserve LINDA Burlingame Google San Mateo Foster City Montara Map data ©2019 Google 2 mi via US-101 N. Fastest route now due to traffic conditions 23 min 13.9 miles A via 1-280 N Some traffic, as usual 27 min 18.4 miles https://www.google.com/maps/dir/San+Francisco+International+Airport+(SFO),+San+Francisco,+CA/US+District+Court+Clerk, +450+Golden+Gate+Av... 1/1 2 Exhibit 13 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docufrente Badges F#MaCu24/19 Page 35 of 42 Courts & Judges Counsel Parties Cases Documents Patents Apps Alexis Pfeiffer Product Update: Report threshold increased from 2,000 to 150,000 cases and new Motions analytics tab added. Learn more in our Help Center. Search all of Lex Machina Courts & Judges Search for Courts Court name Search includes District Courts, PTAB, ITC, and Delaware Court of Chancery. Search for Judges Judge name Search includes District, Magistrate, PTAB, ITC, and Delaware Court of Chancery judges. Top 5 Courts by Case Filings 2015-2019 Expand Antitrust E.D.Pa. 316 N.D.Cal. 272 S.D.N.Y. 264 E.D. Mich. 218 D.D.C. 188 Copyright C.D.Cal. 3,211 S.D.N.Y. 3,097 N.D.III. 1,384 D.N.J. 1,222 https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 1/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docurferlist Badges FREMCHIN24/19 Page 36 of 42 N.D.Cal. 985 Patent E.D.Tex. 5,684 D.Del. 2,974 C.D.Cal. 1,297 N.D.Cal. 1,032 D.N.J. 911 Securities S.D.N.Y. 1,126 N.D.Cal. 586 D.Del. 465 410 C.D.Cal. D.N.J. 329 ► All District Court Case Filings by Year Top 5 District Judges by Case Filings 2015-2019 Expand Antitrust Cynthia M. Rufe (CMR) 250 E.D.Pa. 185 Marianne O. Battani (MOB) E.D. Mich. 115 Colleen Kollar-Kotelly (CK) D.D.C. Jose L. Linares (JLL) D.N.J. Janis Lynn Sammartino (ILS) S.D.Cal. Copyright 261 Wiley Young Daniel (WYD) D.Colo. 239 William Haskell Alsup (WHA) N.D.Cal. 215 Christina A. Snyder (CAS) C.D.Cal. Terry J. Hatter Jr. (TJH) 190 https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 2/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docurforeret Badges Ffe Macm24/19 Page 37 of 42 C.D.Cal. George H. Wu (GHW) 175 C.D.Cal. Patent 3,755 James Rodney Gilstrap (JRG) E.D.Tex. Robert William Schroeder III (RWS) 1,755 E.D.Tex. Richard Gibson Andrews (RGA) 854 D.Del. Leonard Philip Stark (LPS) 853 D.Del. 571 Gregory Moneta Sleet (GMS) D.Del. Securities 122 Richard Gibson Andrews (RGA) D.Del. 120 Leonard Philip Stark (LPS) D.Del. Maryellen Noreika (MN) D.Del. Colm Felix Connolly (CFC) D.Del. Richard G. Seeborg (RGS) N.D.Cal. → Top 100 District Judges by Case Filings Top 5 Magistrate Judges by Case Filings 2015-2019 Expand Antitrust Mona K Majzoub (MKM) E.D. Mich. Mitchell D Dembin (MDD) S.D.Cal. Joseph A Dickson (JAD) D.N.J. Nathanael Cousins (NC) N.D.Cal. James R Klindt (JRK) https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 3/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docur frente Badges pie Macina24/19 Page 38 of 42 M.D.Fla. Copyright 275 Steven I Locke (SIL) E.D.NY. 255 Michael E Hegarty (MEH) D.Colo. Michael R Wilner (MRW) 241 C.D.Cal. 209 Charles F Eick (CFE) C.D.Cal. 205 Frederick F Mumm (FFM) C.D.Cal. Patent 2,393 Roy Payne (RP) E.D.Tex. 540 Christopher J Burke (CJB) D.Del. 406 John D Love (JDL) E.D.Tex. 289 K Nicole Mitchell (KNM) E.D.Tex. 237 Sherry R Fallon (SRF) D.Del. Securities Lois H Goodman (LHG) D.N.J. Nathanael Cousins (NC) N.D.Cal. Cathy L Waldor (CLW) D.N.J. John E McDermott (JEM) C.D.Cal. Leda Dunn Wettre (LDW) D.N.J. Districts First Circuit https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 4/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docurfreunde Badges pie Macina24/19 Page 39 of 42 District of Maine (D.Me.) District of Massachusetts (D.Mass.) District of New Hampshire (D.N.H.) District of Rhode Island (D.R.I.) District of Puerto Rico (D.P.R.) Second Circuit District of Connecticut (D.Conn.) Northern District of New York (N.D.N.Y.) Eastern District of New York (E.D.N.Y.) Southern District of New York (S.D.N.Y.) Western District of New York (W.D.N.Y.) District of Vermont (D.Vt.) Third Circuit District of Delaware (D.Del.) District of New Jersey (D.N.J.) Eastern District of Pennsylvania (E.D.Pa.) Middle District of Pennsylvania (M.D.Pa.) Western District of Pennsylvania (W.D.Pa.) District of Virgin Islands (D.V.I.) Fourth Circuit District of Maryland (D.Md.) Eastern District of North Carolina (E.D.N.C.). Middle District of North Carolina (M.D.N.C.) Western District of North Carolina (W.D.N.C.) District of South Carolina (D.S.C.) Eastern District of Virginia (E.D.Va.) Western District of Virginia (W.D.Va.) Northern District of West Virginia (N.D.W.Va.) Southern District of West Virginia (S.D.W.Va.) Fifth Circuit Western District of Louisiana (W.D.La.) Northern District of Mississippi (N.D. Miss.) Southern District of Mississippi (S.D. Miss.) Northern District of Texas (N.D.Tex.) Eastern District of Texas (E.D.Tex.) https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 5/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docufferte & Pages FieMaH24/19 Page 40 of 42 Southern District of Texas (S.D. Tex.) Western District of Texas (W.D.Tex.) Eastern District of Louisiana (E.D.La.) Middle District of Louisiana (M.D.la.) Sixth Circuit Eastern District of Kentucky (E.D.Ky.) Western District of Kentucky (W.D.Ky.) Eastern District of Michigan (E.D. Mich.) Western District of Michigan (W.D. Mich.) Northern District of Ohio (N.D.Ohio) Southern District of Ohio (S.D.Ohio) Eastern District of Tennessee (E.D.Tenn.) Middle District of Tennessee (M.D.Tenn.) Western District of Tennessee (W.D.Tenn.) Seventh Circuit Northern District of Illinois (N.D.III.) Central District of Illinois (C.D.III.) Southern District of Illinois (S.D.III.) Northern District of Indiana (N.D.Ind.) Southern District of Indiana (S.D.Ind.) Eastern District of Wisconsin (E.D.Wis.) Western District of Wisconsin (W.D.Wis.) Eighth Circuit Eastern District of Arkansas (E.D.Ark.) Western District of Arkansas (W.D.Ark.) Northern District of lowa (N.D.Iowa) Southern District of lowa (S.D.lowa) District of Minnesota (D. Minn.) Eastern District of Missouri (E.D.Mo.) Western District of Missouri (W.D.Mo.) District of Nebraska (D.Neb.) District of North Dakota (D.N.D.) District of South Dakota (D.S.D.) Ninth Circuit https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 6/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-cv-00023-ADA Docur frente Bridges Fife Machina24/19 Page 41 of 42 District of Arizona (D.Ariz.) Northern District of California (N.D.Cal.) Eastern District of California (E.D.Cal.) Central District of California (C.D.Cal.) Southern District of California (S.D.Cal.) District of Hawaii (D.Haw.) District of Idaho (D.Idaho) District of Montana (D. Mont.) District of Nevada (D. Nev.) District of Oregon (D.Or.) Eastern District of Washington (E.D.Wash.). Western District of Washington (W.D.Wash.) District of Guam (D.Guam) District of Northern Mariana Islands (D.N. Mar.l.) District of Alaska (D.Alaska) Tenth Circuit District of Colorado (D.Colo.) District of Kansas (D. Kan.) District of New Mexico (D.N.M.) Northern District of Oklahoma (N.D.Okla.) Eastern District of Oklahoma (E.D.Okla.) Western District of Oklahoma (W.D.Okla.) District of Utah (D.Utah) District of Wyoming (D.Wyo.) Eleventh Circuit Northern District of Alabama (N.D.Ala.) Middle District of Alabama (M.D.Ala.) Southern District of Alabama (S.D.Ala.) Northern District of Florida (N.D.Fla.) Middle District of Florida (M.D.Fla.) Southern District of Florida (S.D.Fla.) Northern District of Georgia (N.D.Ga.) Middle District of Georgia (M.D.Ga.) Southern District of Georgia (S. D.Ga.) https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 7/8 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Docurferlist Badges FREMCHIN24/19 Page 42 of 42 District of Columbia Circuit District of Columbia (D.D.C.) https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ 8/8 2 122.5653641,11 z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x808f778c55555555:0xa4f25c571a acde3f!2m2!1d- 122.3789554!2d37.6213129!1m5!1m1!1s0x8085809alb71c355:Oxfb7672863e286a17!2m2!1d- 122.4181757!2d37.7819798!3e0 (last visited April 23, 2019). 15. Attached as Exhibit 13 is a true correct copy of a printout from Lex Machina showing the number of patent cases filed in different districts, available at https://law.lexmachina.com/court/ (last visited April 23, 2019). I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on April 24, 2019. Gata Gregory H. Lantier 2 Exhibit 1 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023DAD Skape Dimiter leishtaBQue Camperu ofarmation 9Visprade 7 of 42 Data Scape Limited Summary Latest Updates Credit Score Business Checks Company Summary Data Scape Limited was set up on Tuesday the 3rd of January 2017. Their current partial address is Dublin 18 Ireland, and the company status is Normal. The company's current directors have been the director of 388 other Irish companies between them; 50 of which are now closed. Data Scape Limited has 4 shareholders. Company Name: Data Scape Limited Company Status: NORMAL Company Address: Office 115, 4-5 Burton Hall Road, Sandyford, Dublin 18 Ireland Key Executive: Mr O'Gara Company Size: Log-In To View Key Contact Profile Mr O'Gara is a Company Director of Data Scape Limited since 2017 and a listed Director of 3 other companies. Generate a B2B Marketing List with ease and grow your business. Identify key decision makers and pre-qualified new prospects for your sales and business development teams. Similar Companies - Create a marketing list of similar companies https://www.vision-net.ie/Company Info/Data-Scape-Limited-595810 1/8 2 Exhibit 2 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documentele cape pilted 04/24/19 Page 9 of 42 © 2019 Hopkins Bruce Publishers, Corp. Docket Navigator Data Scape Limited Cases Parties Data Scape Limited VIEW IN BROWSER Case Case Filing Date Certain Data Transmission Devices, Components Thereof, Associated Software, and Products Containing the Same; Inv. No. 337-TA-1150 337-TA-1150 (ITC) Mar. 01, 2019 Feb. 27, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Verizon Communications Inc. et al 6-19-cv-00174 (TXWD) Data Scape Limited v. Dell Technologies Inc. et al 6-19-cv-00129 (TXWD) Feb. 13, 2019 Feb. 11, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Teradata Operations, Inc. 2-19-cv-01002 (CACD) Feb. 08, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Fujitsu America, Inc. et al 6-19-cv-00046 (TXED) Feb. 07, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Barracuda Networks, Inc. 1-19-CV-00179 (CAED) Jan. 25, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Dropbox, Inc. 6-19-CV-00023 (TXWD) Data Scape Limited v. Box, Inc. 6-19-cv-00025 (TXWD) Jan. 25, 2019 Jan. 18, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Dropbox, Inc. 1-19-cv-00048 (TXWD) Jan. 09, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. Amazon.com, Inc. et al 1-19-CV-00056 (COD) Jan. 09, 2019 Data Scape Limited v. F5 Networks, Inc. 1-19-CV-00064 (COD) Data Scape Limited v. Dell Technologies, Inc. et al 6-18-CV-00658 (TXED) Dec. 27, 2018 Dec. 27, 2018 Data Scape Limited v. PFU (EMEA) Limited et al 6-18-cv-00659 (TXED) Dec. 27, 2018 Data Scape Limited v. SAP America, Inc. et al 6-18-cv-00660 (TXED) Data Scape Limited v. Spotify USA Inc. et al 2-18-CV-10653 (CACD) Dec. 26, 2018 Dec. 26, 2018 Data Scape Limited v. Pandora Media, Inc. 2-18-cv-10656 (CACD) Dec. 26, 2018 Data Scape Limited v. Citrix System, Inc. 2-18-cv-10658 (CACD) Data Scape Limited v. Apple Inc. 2-18-cv-10659 (CACD) Dec. 26, 2018 Dec. 26, 2018 Data Scape Limited v. Western Digital Corporation et al 8-18-cv-02285 (CACD) https://compass.docketnavigator.com/patent/party/486769/3?print=true 1/1 4/23/2019 Case 6:19-CV-00023-ADA Documenpapscapeffimated 04/24/19 Page 10 of 42 © 2019 Hopkins Bruce Publishers, Corp. Docket Navigator Data Scape Limited Asserted Patents Patentees Data Scape Limited VIEW IN BROWSER Patent a Patent Name First Inventor Grant Date 10027751 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi Jul. 17, 2018 7239469 Recording apparatus, server apparatus, recording method, program, and storage medium Hirano Jul. 03, 2007 7617537 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi Nov. 10, 2009 7720929 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi May. 18, 2010 Feb. 26, 2013 8386581 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi 9380112 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi Jun. 28, 2016 9712614 Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method Morohashi Jul. 18, 2017 9715893 Hirano Jul. 25, 2017 Recording apparatus, server apparatus, recording method, program and storage medium Communication system and its method and communication apparatus and its method 9736238 Morohashi Aug. 15, 2017 https://compass.docketnavigator.com/patent/party/486769/4?print=true 1/1