Data Scape Limited v. Dropbox, Inc.

Western District of Texas, txwd-6:2019-cv-00023

Exhibit 1

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

3 Exhibit 1 012013425 6278ÿ 37-2 Case 6:19-cv-00023-ADA Document ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 05/15/19 Page 2 of 23 sx y F ghiÿkhlmnomÿphll qrhÿsÿtruvw 4567869:;<ÿ>5;<?@A?6ÿB;CÿD5E; F GHIÿKLMÿNOÿGPPLHOIQRÿSÿTIÿOIIUÿVLHIÿNPPLHOIQWÿXOÿQLMHÿNHINYÿGZZ[QÿOL\ÿ]LHÿVIV^IHW_XZY `5E;aEÿAE;5?bÿ;cE5a dEAA;e@<e f5Cÿ;e;@< ent ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 05/15/19 Page 3 of 23 tw x y oWcÿpWYqQVqÿrWYY sUWÿtÿuU]Sv 45678 9:;<=8ÿ?6;78@6=A B6CC7=@8DÿE7@F<;@=<A B:G<<GA H:GI<8@=Jÿ?6;78@6=A iG@K:_Dÿjÿ9<GCAÿ 4FK<G8@A@=J ?:;<Aÿ?6;78@6=A H65@;< ?C:;;ÿL7A@=<AA ?:M<8DÿB<=8<G N7<A8@6=AO dYZYfSÿgh]eVheY PQRQSÿUVWÿXYZ[ÿ\Y]SYW^ k=J;@Alÿmk=J;@Aln H:=:J<ÿD67Gÿ:__67=8ÿ:=Fÿ`G@K:_Da bUÿSUÿcUVWÿdYSSQ]eR^ H<AA:J@=J 9GDÿ:J:@= ent ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 4 of 23 v{ | D jklÿnkopqrpÿskoo tukÿvÿwuxyz 2345647 89:ÿ<39:=>?=4ÿ@9AÿB3C9 D EFGHFIÿKLÿHFÿMNOPQRGRSOÿTÿLUUGOÿFRVÿWRXÿMIUUIXYHFIZNÿRFGHFIÿKLÿHFÿMNOPQRGRSOÿUXRSX[\]ÿ^Rÿ_`aÿXIbZY] c3C9dCÿ?C93=eÿ9fC3d gC??9h>:h i3Aÿ9h9>: 7 11 ent 6789 637-2 ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 5 of 23 23456 789:;6ÿ=4956>4;? @4AA5ru;>6Bÿ C5>D:9>;v:? w mUaÿnUWoOToÿpUWW @8E::E? F8EG:6>;Hÿ=4956>4;? gE>I8]Bÿhÿ7:EA?ÿ qSUÿrÿsS[Qt 2DI:E6>?>;H =89:?ÿ=4956>4;? F43>9: =A899ÿJ5?>;:?? =8K:6Bÿ@:;6:E L5:?6>4;?M bWXWdQÿef[cTfcW NOPOQÿSTUÿVWXYÿZW[QWU\ i;H9>?jÿki;H9>?jl F8;8H:ÿB45Eÿ8]]45;6ÿ8;Dÿ^E>I8]B_ `SÿQSÿaSTUÿbWQQO[cP\ F:??8H>;H 7EBÿ8H8>; 7 11 ent ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 6 of 23 „ D stuÿwtxyz{yÿ|txx }~tÿÿ€~‚ƒ 2345647 89:ÿ<39:=>?=4ÿ@9AÿB3C9 D EFGÿEIJÿEKLMNÿOMPQGKRÿSÿTLNNLIUÿVINNMKÿWXYIZM[GRÿ\IK]^_ÿ`LUZGÿabbc_ÿWKGÿQI]ÿd]MNLeLGXf g3C9hCÿ?C93=iÿ9jC3h kC93:ÿl43C kC93:ÿl43C qC??9r>:r n3Aÿ9r9>: B64mh n9jC:hÿ84jmh>4:? g4llm:>hAÿom>pCj>:C? 7 11 ent 6789 637-2 ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 7 of 23 2345546 734859:;<ÿ>?@A9:?;6 e4:D3q[tIÿfÿg54F6ÿ u v lS_ÿmSUnMRnÿoSUU BCD549:6:;< >3@56ÿ>?@A9:?;6 7?E:@5 pQSÿqÿrQYOs >F3@@ÿGA6:;566 >3H59Iÿ25;954 JA569:?;6K `UVUbOÿcdYaRdaU LMNMOÿQRSÿTUVWÿXUYOUSZ h;<@:6iÿjh;<@:6ik 73;3<5ÿI?A4ÿ3[[?A;9ÿ3;Cÿ\4:D3[I] ^QÿOQÿ_QRSÿ`UOOMYaNZ 75663<:;< g4Iÿ3<3:; 7 11 ent ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 8 of 23 ty z D hijÿlimnopnÿqimm rsiÿtÿusvwx 2345647 89:ÿ<39:=>?=4ÿ@9AÿB3C9 D EFGÿIJKÿLMÿENNJFMGOPÿQÿRGÿMGGSÿTJFGÿLNNJFMGOUÿVMÿOJKFÿLFGLWÿEXXYOÿMJZÿ[JFÿTGT\GFU]VX^ _3C9`Cÿ?C93=aÿ9bC3` cC93:ÿd43C cC93:ÿd43C eC??9f>:f g3Aÿ9f9>: 7 11 ent 6789 637-2 ÿ ÿ ÿFiled ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 9 of 23 ru v w mUaÿnUWoOToÿpUWW qSUÿrÿsS[Qt 23456 789:;6ÿ=4956>4;? @4AA5;>6BÿC5>D:9>;:? @8E::E? F8EG:6>;Hÿ=4956>4;? gE>I8]Bÿhÿ7:EA?ÿ 2DI:E6>?>;H =89:?ÿ=4956>4;? F43>9: =A899ÿJ5?>;:?? =8K:6Bÿ@:;6:E L5:?6>4;?M bWXWdQÿef[cTfcW NOPOQÿSTUÿVWXYÿZW[QWU\ i;H9>?jÿki;H9>?jl F8;8H:ÿB45Eÿ8]]45;6ÿ8;Dÿ^E>I8]B_ `SÿQSÿaSTUÿbWQQO[cP\ F:??8H>;H 7EBÿ8H8>; 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 10 of 23 •˜ ™ D { ÿ‘{}’uz’ÿ“{}} ”y{ÿ•ÿ–yw— 2345647 89:ÿ<39:=>?=4ÿ@9AÿB3C9 D EFGHFIÿKLÿHFÿMNOPQRGRSOÿTÿLUUGOÿFRVÿWRXÿMIUUIXYHFIZNÿRFGHFIÿKLÿHFÿMNOPQRGRSOÿUXRSX[\]ÿ^Rÿ_`aÿXIbZY] c3C9dCÿ?C93=eÿ9fC3d gC93:ÿh43C gC93:ÿh43C B64id j9fC:dÿ84fid>4:? c4hhi:>dAÿki>lCf>:C? c93CC3? m93nCd>:oÿ84fid>4:? ‹3>p9=AÿŒÿjC3h?ÿ BlpC3d>?>:o 89fC?ÿ84fid>4:? m46>fC 8h9ffÿ@i?>:C?? 89qCdAÿcC:dC3 riC?d>4:?s †}~}ˆwÿ‰Š‡zŠ‡} mC??9o>:o tuvuwÿyz{ÿ|}~ÿ€}w}{‚ :of>?eÿŽ:of>?e m9:9oCÿA4i3ÿ9==4i:dÿ9:lÿ53>p9=Aƒ „yÿwyÿ yz{ÿ†}wwu‡v‚ j3Aÿ9o9>: 7 11 ent ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 05/15/19 Page 11 of 23 y~  G mnoÿqnrstusÿvnrr wxnÿyÿzx{|} 567897:;<=ÿ?6<=@AB@7ÿC<DÿE6F< G HIJKLIÿNÿOKJPNQÿRKSTISÿUÿVKLWQIXIÿYKZSÿ[N\XISÿK]ÿOKJPNQÿRKSTÿP^ÿN\ÿQPXXQIÿN\ÿ_ÿYINSÿ`PXaÿbOVc d6F<eFÿBF<6@fÿ<gF6e hF<6=ÿi76F hF<6=ÿi76F jFBB<kA=k l6Dÿ<k<A= ent ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 05/15/19 Page 12 of 23 ux y z pXdÿqXZrRWrÿsXZZ tVXÿuÿvV^Tw 56789:;<=>9ÿ@7<89A7>B C7DD8>A9EÿF8AG=<A>=B C;H==HB I;HJ=9A>Kÿ@7<89A7>B jHAL;`Eÿkÿ:=HDBÿ 5GL=H9ABA>K @;<=Bÿ@7<89A7>B I76A<= @D;<<ÿM8BA>=BB @;N=9EÿC=>9=H O8=B9A7>BP eZ[ZgTÿhi^fWifZ QRSRTÿVWXÿYZ[\ÿ]Z^TZX_ l>K<ABmÿnl>K<ABmo I;>;K=ÿE78Hÿ;``78>9ÿ;>GÿaHAL;`Eb cVÿTVÿdVWXÿeZTTR^fS_ I=BB;KA>K:HEÿ;K;A> ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 13 of 23 w| } E klmÿolpqrsqÿtlpp uvlÿwÿxvyz{ 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHIJGÿLÿMIHNLOÿPIQRGQÿSÿTIJUOGVGÿWIXQÿYLZVGQÿI[ÿMIHNLOÿPIQRÿN\ÿLZÿONVVOGÿLZÿ]ÿWGLQÿ^NV_ÿ`MTa b4D:cDÿ@D:4>dÿ:eD4c fD:4;ÿg54D fD:4;ÿg54D hD@@:i?;i j4Bÿ:i:?; 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 14 of 23 sv w x nVbÿoVXpPUpÿqVXX rTVÿsÿtT\Ru 34567 89:;<7ÿ>5:67?5<@ A5BB6<?7CÿD6?E;:?<;@ A9F;;F@ G9FH;7?<Iÿ>5:67?5<@ hF?J9^Cÿiÿ8;FB@ÿ 3EJ;F7?@?<I >9:;@ÿ>5:67?5<@ G54?:; >B9::ÿK6@?<;@@ >9L;7CÿA;<7;F M6;@7?5<@N cXYXeRÿfg\dUgdX OPQPRÿTUVÿWXYZÿ[X\RXV] j<I:?@kÿlj<I:?@km G9<9I;ÿC56Fÿ9^^56<7ÿ9<Eÿ_F?J9^C` aTÿRTÿbTUVÿcXRRP\dQ] G;@@9I?<I 8FCÿ9I9?< 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 15 of 23 uz { E ijkÿmjnopqoÿrjnn stjÿuÿvtwxy 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHIJGÿLÿMIHNLOÿPIQRGQÿSÿTIJUOGVGÿWIXQÿYLZVGQÿI[ÿMIHNLOÿPIQRÿN\ÿLZÿONVVOGÿLZÿ]ÿWGLQÿ^NV_ÿ`MTa b4D:cDÿ@D:4>dÿ:eD4c fD@@:g?;g h4Bÿ:g:?; 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 16 of 23 sv w x nVbÿoVXpPUpÿqVXX rTVÿsÿtT\Ru 34567 89:;<7ÿ>5:67?5<@ A5BB6<?7CÿD6?E;:?<;@ A9F;;F@ G9FH;7?<Iÿ>5:67?5<@ hF?J9^Cÿiÿ8;FB@ÿ 3EJ;F7?@?<I >9:;@ÿ>5:67?5<@ G54?:; >B9::ÿK6@?<;@@ >9L;7CÿA;<7;F M6;@7?5<@N cXYXeRÿfg\dUgdX OPQPRÿTUVÿWXYZÿ[X\RXV] j<I:?@kÿlj<I:?@km G9<9I;ÿC56Fÿ9^^56<7ÿ9<Eÿ_F?J9^C` aTÿRTÿbTUVÿcXRRP\dQ] G;@@9I?<I 8FCÿ9I9?< 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 17 of 23 w| } E klmÿolpqrsqÿtlpp uvlÿwÿxvyz{ 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHIJGÿLÿMIHNLOÿPIQRGQÿSÿTIJUOGVGÿWIXQÿYLZVGQÿI[ÿMIHNLOÿPIQRÿN\ÿLZÿONVVOGÿLZÿ]ÿWGLQÿ^NV_ÿ`MTa b4D:cDÿ@D:4>dÿ:eD4c fD:4;ÿg54D fD:4;ÿg54D hD@@:i?;i j4Bÿ:i:?; 7 11 ent 6789 37-2 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 18 of 23 34567 89:;<7ÿ>5:67?5<@ A5BB6sv <?7Cÿ D6?E;:?<w;@ x nVbÿoVXpPUpÿqVXX A9F;;F@ G9FH;7?<Iÿ>5:67?5<@ hF?J9^Cÿiÿ8;FB@ÿ rTVÿsÿtT\Ru 3EJ;F7?@?<I >9:;@ÿ>5:67?5<@ G54?:; >B9::ÿK6@?<;@@ >9L;7CÿA;<7;F M6;@7?5<@N cXYXeRÿfg\dUgdX OPQPRÿTUVÿWXYZÿ[X\RXV] j<I:?@kÿlj<I:?@km G9<9I;ÿC56Fÿ9^^56<7ÿ9<Eÿ_F?J9^C` aTÿRTÿbTUVÿcXRRP\dQ] G;@@9I?<I 8FCÿ9I9?< 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 19 of 23 }‚ ƒ E qrsÿurvwxywÿzrvv {|rÿ}ÿ~|€ 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHÿFJKÿFLMNOÿPNQRHLSÿTÿUMOOMJVÿWJOONLÿXYZJ[N\HSÿ]JL^_`ÿaMV[Hÿbccd`ÿXLHÿRJ^ÿe^NOMfMHYg h4D:iDÿ@D:4>jÿ:kD4i lD:4;ÿm54D lD:4;ÿm54D nD@@:o?;o p4Bÿ:o:?; 7 11 ent 6789 37-2 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 20 of 23 sv w x nVbÿoVXpPUpÿqVXX rTVÿsÿtT\Ru 34567 89:;<7ÿ>5:67?5<@ A5BB6<?7CÿD6?E;:?<;@ A9F;;F@ G9FH;7?<Iÿ>5:67?5<@ hF?J9^Cÿiÿ8;FB@ÿ 3EJ;F7?@?<I >9:;@ÿ>5:67?5<@ G54?:; >B9::ÿK6@?<;@@ >9L;7CÿA;<7;F M6;@7?5<@N cXYXeRÿfg\dUgdX OPQPRÿTUVÿWXYZÿ[X\RXV] j<I:?@kÿlj<I:?@km G9<9I;ÿC56Fÿ9^^56<7ÿ9<Eÿ_F?J9^C` aTÿRTÿbTUVÿcXRRP\dQ] G;@@9I?<I 8FCÿ9I9?< 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 21 of 23 w| } E klmÿolpqrsqÿtlpp uvlÿwÿxvyz{ 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHIJGÿLÿMIHNLOÿPIQRGQÿSÿTIJUOGVGÿWIXQÿYLZVGQÿI[ÿMIHNLOÿPIQRÿN\ÿLZÿONVVOGÿLZÿ]ÿWGLQÿ^NV_ÿ`MTa b4D:cDÿ@D:4>dÿ:eD4c fD:4;ÿg54D fD:4;ÿg54D hD@@:i?;i j4Bÿ:i:?; 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 22 of 23 sv w x nVbÿoVXpPUpÿqVXX rTVÿsÿtT\Ru 34567 89:;<7ÿ>5:67?5<@ A5BB6<?7CÿD6?E;:?<;@ A9F;;F@ G9FH;7?<Iÿ>5:67?5<@ hF?J9^Cÿiÿ8;FB@ÿ 3EJ;F7?@?<I >9:;@ÿ>5:67?5<@ G54?:; >B9::ÿK6@?<;@@ >9L;7CÿA;<7;F M6;@7?5<@N cXYXeRÿfg\dUgdX OPQPRÿTUVÿWXYZÿ[X\RXV] j<I:?@kÿlj<I:?@km G9<9I;ÿC56Fÿ9^^56<7ÿ9<Eÿ_F?J9^C` aTÿRTÿbTUVÿcXRRP\dQ] G;@@9I?<I 8FCÿ9I9?< 7 11 ent 6ÿ ÿ Filed ÿ ÿ 9 05/15/19 9 Page 23 of 23 “– — E Žyƒÿy{sxÿ‘y{{ ’wyÿ“ÿ”wu• 3456758 9:;ÿ=4:;>?@>5ÿA:BÿC4D: E FGHIJGÿLÿMIHNLOÿPIQRGQÿSÿTIJUOGVGÿWIXQÿYLZVGQÿI[ÿMIHNLOÿPIQRÿN\ÿLZÿONVVOGÿLZÿ]ÿWGLQÿ^NV_ÿ`MTa b4D:cDÿ@D:4>dÿ:eD4c kD@@:m?;m C75fc g:eD;cÿ95efc?5;@ b5hhf;?cBÿif?jDe?;D@ b:4DD4@ k:4lDc?;mÿ95efc?5;@ ‰4?n:>BÿŠÿgD4h@ÿ CjnD4c?@?;m 9:eD@ÿ95efc?5;@ k57?eD 9h:eeÿAf@?;D@@ 9:oDcBÿbD;cD4 pfD@c?5;@q „{|{†uÿ‡ˆ xˆ { rstsuÿwxyÿz{|}ÿ~{u{y€ ‹;me?@dÿŒ‹;me?@d k:;:mDÿB5f4ÿ:>>5f;cÿ:;jÿ64?n:>B g4Bÿ:m:?; ‚wÿuwÿƒwxyÿ„{uus t€ 7 11 9 9 17 1 7 71 1! " # $ 9%&0'6 7&()*+6&0,-! . 7 / 98%&0'62013026&0,- 8 7%789 - $2 212