Data Scape Limited v. Dropbox, Inc.

Western District of Texas, txwd-6:2019-cv-00023

Exhibit 8)(Ravel, J.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

Exhibit 8 012013425 6789 37-9 Case 6:19-cv-00023-ADA Document 97ÿ Filed ÿ 9 9 05/15/19 Page 2 of 3 5ÿ789:ÿ;<=>?@AÿBCDEFÿGDHI?AJFCAKÿL<C=M "#$%&'()%#ÿ+'(,-.()ÿ/%0,(%1, 2%3.ÿ,'ÿ4%$.0,').0 NOPOÿRSTUVSWUÿXYZVUTÿ[\]\^ÿW_T`Ta X|_S}ÿXY~TUVZWUSY~ Œ_U`~U``ÿR`WSTSY~T GfdF@dFFÿ€ ‚@nC?@kFcF@d GfdF@dÿ@<dÿ?@jfI?g GfdF@dÿF@n<CEFfHIF Œ_U`~UÿX_||`~Ž`VÿR`WSTSY~T GfdF@dÿLJfIIF@kFCƒ i<@?@nC?@kFcF@d GfdF@dÿ?@jfI?g GfdF@dÿD@F@n<CEFfƒ `}`S`T hfcfkFA b„ †GCFI?cÿ‚@‡Ed ‚@‡Ed† @k<?@kÿ„<sƒ o@J@Egÿhfc†ˆddsÿxƒ €f@Ed?<@A ‘VS_|T DCsÿbC?fI BF@EJÿbC?fI ‘V_~T’`VTÿ“ÿPU_”T bCf@AnFC €dfs ‘`V}S~_USY~ ‰?>FIsÿ€FddIFcF@d fdDCFÿbFCc?@fd?<@ Š‹‹`_| 9sC 7sC ysC wsC qsC zsC {sC bJFÿc?IFAd<@FAÿAJ<e@ÿ?@ÿdJ?AÿEJfCdÿfCFÿHfAFgÿ<@ÿh<E>Fdÿifj?kfd<ClAÿEIfAA?mEfd?<@ÿ<nÿ<CgFCAÿcfdEJ?@kÿdJFÿAFfCEJÿEC?dFC?fÿA=FE?mFgÿd<ÿkF@FCfdFÿdJFÿCF=<CdMÿofEJÿH<pÿ=I<dÿAJ<eAÿdJF d?cFÿHFdeFF@ÿdJFÿmI?@kÿ<nÿdJFÿE<c=If?@dÿf@gÿdJFÿ@fcFgÿc?IFAd<@FMÿbJFÿIFndÿf@gÿC?kJdÿF@gAÿ<nÿdJFÿH<pÿIfHFIFgÿq8rÿfCFÿCFA=FEd?jFIsÿdJFÿmCAdtÿf@gÿdJ?CgtuDfCd?IFAMÿbJFÿI?kJdFCÿI?@F AJ<eAÿFjF@dAÿHFdeFF@ÿdJFÿ7@gÿf@gÿ:vdJÿ=FCEF@d?IFMÿbJFÿCFcf?@?@kÿ=<?@dAÿfCFÿ<DdI?FCAKÿCF=CFAF@dÿfdÿc<Adÿwrÿ<nÿdJFÿgfdfKÿf@gÿfCFÿ@<dÿAJ<e@KÿJ<eFjFCKÿdJFÿdCDFÿc?@?cDcÿf@g cfp?cDcÿfCFÿ?@EIDgFgÿ?@ÿdJFÿfEE<c=f@s?@kÿdfHIFÿf@gÿdJFÿcFf@ÿ?@EIDgFAÿ<DdI?FCAMÿxFeFCÿdJf@ÿdF@ÿFjF@dAÿ<EEDCC?@kÿ?@ÿfÿEfdFk<CsÿfCFÿAJ<e@ÿfAÿg<dAÿ?@AdFfgÿ<nÿfÿH<pÿ=I<dMÿ ÿ 11 7 ent 97ÿ Filed ÿ 9 9 05/15/19 Page 3 of 3 "#$#ÿ&'()*'+)ÿ,-.*)(/001234035 6747818 94:ÿ<32034=7>3 ?725=ÿ@1A2=7>3 63:7A4 BC72:ÿ@1A2=7>3 DE=Cÿ<32034=7>3 6AF7818 GH32AI3 J>A78ÿJK45=210=7K4 LMN OPQL NQR MPQR MSQS 9PQS TPQE NEQL MDQN <A=34=33ÿ6UV MMT 9QL NQD MDQT 9LQM 9DQE S9Q9 DNQN 9SQ9 W4X274I3834= 9DE PQM PQP MMQR MNQS 9DQT S9QD EEQR 9MQL <A=34=ÿ4K=ÿ74HA>7: PEN 9Q9 PQD M9QE 9MQT PRQ9 N9QP DEQS 9PQP <A=34=ÿ34XK203AY>3 DD 9Q9 PQP TQD MMQR 9LQR LEQM EEQR MSQE <A=34=ÿJCA>>34I32ÿ6UV PDP RQL TQP MSQM 99QL 9DQD SRQP EEQM 9LQR ZK474X274I3834= LPM MQM EQN MEQS 9TQR PPQM N9QP DEQS 9NQS <A=34=ÿ74HA>7: PEP 9QL PQL NQP MNQD 9TQ9 TPQR N9QP MDQP <A=34=ÿ1434XK203AY>3 N MSQP PMQT L9QM 9DQM [A8AI35 MRL EQE MMQE 9MQM 9EQN PSQR ETQM EEQR P9Q9 B\/]<23>78ÿW4^0= DT RQN RQN MQM PQM PQT MEQP MEQP LQM W4^0=]/4IK74Iÿ\K_A>=_ MNT MQR 9Q9 EQM MPQD 9EQE NNQS ERQL 9RQM `4C40:ÿ[A8]G==_ÿ?335 TM LQD EQS MMQR MEQR LSQL NLQ9 NLQ9 9EQS UA40=7K45 9S DQR DQE MPQT 99QE LMQE STQT STQT 9EQN V12_ÿB27A> PRD M9Q9 MPQR 99QT 9EQP PEQL ELQN ETQM PLQL a340CÿB27A> M9 MPQS MTQR MEQD 9SQS PTQP NPQL NPQL 9DQT B2A45X32 D9 ORQR 9QE LQ9 NQL PNQT PNQT SQT U=A_ NTR MQR LQ9 EQT MSQM TSQD MMEQR MPQP b7c3>_ÿU3==>3834= MPM9 RQR RQT PQR TQL EQE PRQM TTQT NQM 6A=123ÿB32874A=7K4 ETE RQM 9QL EQL MNQD 9DQL NRQT MMDQD 9MQL Gdd3A> L99 MQT PQN MRQP 99QN PTQD EPQP MM9QN 9NQ9 11 7 7 9 7 1 7 1 1 12 9 ! 313