Federal Trade Commission v. Directv, Inc. et al

Northern District of California, cand-4:2015-cv-01129

ORDER by Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. Granting {{394}} Stipulation REGARDING ADMISSIBILITY OF CERTAIN ONBOARDING DOCUMENTS.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

1 Eric D. Edmondson, D.C. Bar No. 450294 Jeffrey M. Tillotson, SBN 139372 Erika Wodinsky, Cal. Bar No. 091700 jtillotson@tillotsonlaw.com 2 Jacob A. Snow, Cal. Bar No. 270988 Tillotson Law Boris Yankilovich, Cal Bar No. 257887 750 North Saint Paul Street, Suite 610 3 901 Market Street, Suite 570, Dallas, TX 75201 4 San Francisco, CA 94103 Telephone: (214) 382-3040 (415) 848-5100 / (415) 848-5184 (fax) Pete Marketos, Pro Hac Vice 5 eedmondson@ftc.gov; ewodinsky@ftc.gov; pete.marketos@rgmfirm.com jsnow@ftc.gov; byankilovich@ftc.gov 6 Reese Gordon Marketos LLP 750 North Saint Paul Street, Suite 610 Raymond E. McKown, Cal. Bar No. 150975 Dallas, TX 75201 7 Stacy Procter, Cal. Bar No. 221078 Telephone: (214) 382-9810 8 Kenneth H. Abbe, Cal. Bar No. 172416 10877 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 700 Chad S. Hummel, SBN 139055 9 Los Angeles, CA 90024 chummel@sidley.com (310) 824-4343 / (310) 824-4380 (fax) Mark D. Campbell, SBN 180528 10 rmckown@ftc.gov; sprocter@ftc.gov; mcampbell@sidley.com kabbe@ftc.gov Bridget S. Johnsen, SBN 210778 11 bjohnsen@sidley.com 12 Attorneys for Plaintiff Ryan M. Sandrock, SBN 251781 Federal Trade Commission rsandrock@sidley.com 13 SIDLEY AUSTIN LLP 555 California Street, Suite 2000 14 San Francisco, CA 94104 Telephone: (415) 722-1200 15 Facsimile: (415)772-7400 16 Attorneys for Defendants DIRECTV and DIRECTV, LLC 17 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 18 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 19 OAKLAND DIVISION 20 21 FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION, Case No. 4:15-cv-01129 HSG 22 Plaintiff, Assigned to the Hon. Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. 23 v. STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV 24 DIRECTV, a corporation, ONBOARDING DOCUMENTS 25 and [Local Rule 7-12] 26 DIRECTV, LLC, a limited liability company, 27 Defendants. 28 STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV ONBOARDING DOCUMENTS 4:15-CV-01129-HSG 1 Plaintiff Federal Trade Commission ("FTC") and Defendants DIRECTV and DIRECTV, 2 LLC ("DIRECTV") (collectively, the "parties") jointly stipulate, pursuant to N.D. Cal. Local Rule 7- 3 12, to the admission of the below, which consist of certain categories of documents that were 4 discussed during the trial testimony of Mr. Brad Bentley on August 15 and 16, 2017: 5 Lease Addendum: Trial Exhibit 2388 is an exemplar of a Lease Addendum, admitted on August 6 16, 2017. Mr. Bentley testified that Trial Exhibit 2388 is a one-page equipment lease agreement 7 from 2014 that the customer signed on the date of installation. Tr. 378:17-380:8. Trial Exhibits 846, 8 2387, 2394, 2395, 2396, 2397, 2398, and 2399 are additional Lease Addendums the parties agree to 9 admit. 10 Residential Customer Agreement: Trial Exhibit 2389 is a Residential Customer Agreement, 11 admitted August 16, 2017. Mr. Bentley testified that Trial Exhibit 2389 is a DIRECTV customer 12 agreement effective as of June 2013. Tr. 382:1-383:9. Trial Exhibits 2390, 2400, 2401, 2402, and 13 2403 are additional Residential Customer Agreements the parties agree to admit. 14 Order Confirmation Emails and Letters: Trial Exhibit 2573 is an order confirmation email. Mr. 15 Bentley testified that Trial Exhibit 2573 is a May 2014 order confirmation that DIRECTV either 16 emailed or mailed to customers. Tr. 373:21-378:21. Trial Exhibits 845, 2391, 2449, 2459, 2466, 17 2467, 2468, 2469, 2470, 2472, 2473, 2475, 2477, 2478, 2483, 2485, 2486, 2487, 2489, 2499, 2500, 18 2504, 2505, 2506, 2508, 2509, 2510, 2512, 2514, 2516, 2520, 2521, 2526, 2529, 2532, 2537, 2538, 19 2544, 2546, 2547, 2550, 2551, 2553, 2559, 2561, 2563, 2565, 2566, 2570, 2571, 2573 are additional 20 order confirmation emails and letters the parties agree to admit. 21 First Subscriber Bill: Trial Exhibits 2412 and 2413 are first subscriber bills, admitted August 16, 22 2017. Mr. Bentley testified that Tr. Ex. 2412 is an example of a first month's bill from 2009. Tr. 23 383:10-384:15. He testified that Tr. Ex. 2413 is a bill from a later year that shows changes 24 DIRECTV made to the bill. Tr. 385:1-388:1. Trial Exhibits 2193 and 2414 are additional first 25 subscriber bills the parties agree to admit. 26 27 28 STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV ONBOARDING ADVERTISEMENTS 4:15-CV-01129-HSG 1 1 Dated: August 30, 2017 SIDLEY AUSTIN 2 By: /s/ Chad S. Hummel Chad S. Hummel 3 Attorneys for Defendants DIRECTV and DIRECTV, LLC 4 FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION 5 By: /s/ Eric D. Edmondson 6 Eric D. Edmondson Attorneys for Plaintiff 7 Federal Trade Commission 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV ONBOARDING ADVERTISEMENTS 4:15-CV-01129-HSG 2 1 Pursuant to Civil Local Rule 5-1(i), the filer attests that concurrence in the filing of this 2 document has been obtained from the signatories above. 3 By: /s/ Ryan M. Sandrock 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV ONBOARDING ADVERTISEMENTS 4:15-CV-01129-HSG 3 1 [PROPOSED] ORDER 2 3 PURSUANT TO STIPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED, AND THE DOCUMENTS 4 REFERENCED ABOVE ARE ADMITTED INTO EVIDENCE IN THE TRIAL OF THE ABOVE- 5 CAPTIONED MATTER. 6 Dated: _______________________ 8/31/2017 ___________________________________ HON. HAYWOOD S. GILLIAM, JR. 7 United States District Judge 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSION OF CERTAIN DIRECTV ONBOARDING ADVERTISEMENTS 4:15-CV-01129-HSG 4