Heldt v. Tata Consultancy Services, LTD

Northern District of California, cand-4:2015-cv-01696

ORDER RE: ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO SEAL CERTAIN DOCUMENTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTIONS IN LIMINE NOS. 1,3,11, and 12 re {{535}} Administrative Motion to File Under Seal EXHIBITS TO MOTIONS IN LIMINE NOS. 1, 3, 11, AND 12 filed by Tata Consultancy Services, Ltd, and {{536}} Administrative Motion to File Under Seal EXHIBITS TO MOTIONS IN LIMINE NOS. 1, 3, 11, AND 12 filed by Tata Consultancy Services, Ltd. Signed by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on 10/16/18.

Interested in this case?

Current View

Full Text

1 2 3 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 4 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 5 6 CHRISTOPHER SLAIGHT, ET AL., CASE NO. 15-cv-01696-YGR 7 Plaintiffs, ORDER RE: ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO 8 vs. SEAL CERTAIN DOCUMENTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTIONS IN LIMIINE NOS. 1, 9 TATA CONSULTANCY SERVICES, LTD, 3, 11, AND 12 10 Defendant. Re: Dkt. Nos. 535, 536 11 12 After considering the administrative motion of defendant Tata Consultancy Northern District of California United States District Court 13 Services, Ltd. ("TCS") pursuant to Local Rule 79-5(d) to file under seal certain exhibits 14 submitted in connection with its Motions in Limine ("MIL") Nos. 1, 3, 11 and 12, and the 15 declarations of Michelle M. La Mar ("La Mar Decl." and "La Mar Decl. #2") filed in 16 support of the administrative motion, the Court rules as follows: 17 18 Document or Portion of Evidence Offered in Document Sought Order Support of Sealing 19 to be Sealed 20 MIL#1, A1 (Ex. 1405) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 21 MIL#1, A2 (Ex. 1406) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 22 MIL#1, A3 (Ex. 1407) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 23 24 MIL#1, A4 (Ex. 1408) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 25 MIL#1, A5 (Ex. 1409) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 26 MIL#1, A6 (Ex. 1410) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 27 MIL#1, A7 (Ex. 1411) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 28 Document or Portion of 1 Evidence Offered in Document Sought Order Support of Sealing 2 to be Sealed 3 MIL#1, A8 (Ex. 1412) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 4 MIL#1, A9 (Ex. 1413) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 5 MIL#1, A10 (Ex. 1414) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 6 MIL#1, A11 (Ex. 1415) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 7 8 MIL#1, A12 (Ex. 1416) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 9 MIL#1, A13 (Ex. 1419) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 10 MIL#1, A14 (Ex. 1420) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 11 12 MIL#1, A15 (Ex. 1421) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. Northern District of California United States District Court 13 MIL#1, A16 (Ex. 1422) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 14 MIL#1, A17 (Ex. 1423) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 15 MIL#1, A18 (Ex. 1424) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 16 17 MIL#1, A19 (Ex. 1425) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 18 MIL#1, A20 (Ex. 1426) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 19 MIL#1, A21 (Ex. 1427) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 20 MIL#1, A22 (Ex. 1428) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 21 22 MIL#1, A23 (Ex. 1429) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 23 MIL#1, A24 (Ex. 1441) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 24 MIL#1, A25 (Ex. 1442) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 25 26 MIL#1, A26 (Ex. 1446) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 27 MIL#1, A27 (Ex. 1450) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 28 2 Document or Portion of 1 Evidence Offered in Document Sought Order Support of Sealing 2 to be Sealed 3 MIL#1, A28 (Ex. 1451) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 4 MIL#1, A29 (Ex. 1452) La Mar Decl., ¶ 2. GRANTED. 5 MIL#3, A1 (Ex. 1482) La Mar Decl., ¶ 3. DENIED AS MOOT.1 6 MIL#11, A1 (Ex. 130) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED.2 7 8 MIL#11, A2 (Ex. 181) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 9 MIL#11, A3 (Ex. 225) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 10 MIL#11, A4 (Ex. 264) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 11 12 MIL#11, A5 (Ex. 469) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. Northern District of California United States District Court 13 MIL#11, A6 (Ex. 526) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 14 MIL#11, A7 (Ex. 547) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 15 MIL#11, A8 (Ex. 559) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 16 17 MIL#11, A9 (Ex. 566) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 18 MIL#11, A10 (Ex. 570) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 19 MIL#11, A11 (Ex. 611) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 20 MIL#11, A12 (Ex. 612) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 21 22 23 1 24 Because plaintiffs have withdrawn Exhibit 1482, the Court does not need to consider Document MIL #3, A1. Accordingly, defendant does not need to submit an unredacted version of 25 Document MIL #3, A1 as required by Local Rule 79-5(f). 2 26 This Order is limited in scope and pertains only to defendant's motions in limine. To the extent that the Court allows plaintiffs to introduce at trial documents filed in support of MIL #11 27 and enumerated as such in this Order as provided for in the Court's order addressing the substance of defendant's motions in limine (Dkt. No. 592), this Order shall not provide a basis to seal such 28 documents at trial. 3 Document or Portion of 1 Evidence Offered in Document Sought Order Support of Sealing 2 to be Sealed 3 MIL#11, A13 (Ex. 733) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 4 MIL#11, A14 (Ex. 737) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 5 MIL#11, A15 (Ex. 740) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 6 MIL#11, A16 (Ex. 743) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 7 8 MIL#11, A17 (Ex. 744) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 9 MIL#11, A18 (Ex. 749) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 10 MIL#11, A19 (Ex. 751) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 11 12 MIL#11, A20 (Ex. 752) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. Northern District of California United States District Court 13 MIL#11, A21 (Ex. 754) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 14 MIL#11, A22 (Ex. 755) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 15 MIL#11, A23 (Ex. 761) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 16 17 MIL#11, A24 (Ex. 766) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 18 MIL#11, A25 (Ex. 775) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 19 MIL#11, A26 (Ex. 778) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 20 MIL#11, A27 (Ex. 799) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 21 22 MIL#11, A28 (Ex. 821) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 23 MIL#11, A29 (Ex. 822) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 24 MIL#11, A30 (Ex. 863) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 25 26 MIL#11, A31 (Ex. 1435) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 27 MIL#11, A32 (Ex. 1436) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 28 4 Document or Portion of 1 Evidence Offered in Document Sought Order Support of Sealing 2 to be Sealed 3 MIL#11, A33 (Ex. 1443) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 4 MIL#11, A34 (Ex. 1444) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 5 MIL#11, A35 (Ex. 1445) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 6 MIL#11, A36 (Ex. 1448) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 7 8 MIL#11, A37 (Ex. 1449) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 9 MIL#11, A38 (Ex. 1457) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 10 MIL#11, A39 (Ex. 1459) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 11 12 MIL#11, A40 (Ex. 1461) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. Northern District of California United States District Court 13 MIL#11, A41 (Ex. 1473) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 14 MIL#11, A42 (Ex. 1474) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 15 MIL#11, A43 (Ex. 1477) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 16 17 MIL#11, A44 (Ex. 1478) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. GRANTED. 18 MIL#11, A45 (Ex. 1482) La Mar Decl. #2, ¶ 2. DENIED AS MOOT. 19 MIL#12, A1 (Ex. 1482) La Mar Decl., ¶ 4. DENIED AS MOOT. 20 This Order terminates Docket Numbers 535 and 536. 21 IT IS SO ORDERED. 22 23 Dated: October 16, 2018 24 YVONNE GONZALEZ ROGERS 25 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT JUDGE 26 27 28 5